Bug 1323330

Summary:	hammer puppet-module list --organization ORGNAME --search "author:AUTH AND name:NAME" --order "version": the order is not correct for version numbers that follow semantic versioning
Product:	Red Hat Satellite	Reporter:	Eric Beaudoin <ebeaudoi>
Component:	Hammer	Assignee:	satellite6-bugs <satellite6-bugs>
Status:	CLOSED WONTFIX	QA Contact:	Katello QA List <katello-qa-list>
Severity:	medium	Docs Contact:
Priority:	unspecified
Version:	6.1.0	CC:	inecas, sshtein, sthirugn
Target Milestone:	Unspecified	Keywords:	Triaged
Target Release:	Unused	Flags:	sshtein: needinfo? (inecas)
Hardware:	x86_64
OS:	Linux
Whiteboard:
Fixed In Version:		Doc Type:	Bug Fix
Doc Text:		Story Points:	---
Clone Of:		Environment:
Last Closed:	2018-09-04 18:04:25 UTC	Type:	Bug
Regression:	---	Mount Type:	---
Documentation:	---	CRM:
Verified Versions:		Category:	---
oVirt Team:	---	RHEL 7.3 requirements from Atomic Host:
Cloudforms Team:	---	Target Upstream Version:

Comment 1 Eric Beaudoin 2016-04-01 22:27:22 UTC

Description of problem:
When running the following command, the order is not correct for version numbers that follow semantic versioning:

hammer puppet-module list --organization ORGNAME --search "author:AUTHNAME AND name:NAME" --order "version"

Example:

-------------------------------------|---------|--------|--------
ID                                   | NAME    | AUTHOR | VERSION
-------------------------------------|---------|--------|--------
3cb3f938-e9eb-4593-8fb6-8e7769f0aa2d | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.10 
a7cf5e1b-f4b6-4918-a764-65f0755cc2aa | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.11 
3ac43581-fa92-4bfe-940d-10c9f84f7de3 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.12 
62fad128-f351-41f0-b324-158e1159ed01 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.13 
91851ed8-ba5d-4bcb-89e8-56964637900c | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.14 
ec520faf-3961-4f35-aebb-f957ad4d5d0a | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.15 
17b57717-8925-48ee-9ec6-828ca59c0c40 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.16 
58d0b4cc-3164-4bea-90d1-292176b16241 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.17 
e79d9d12-7c66-4cf8-a169-b9eecc81c717 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.18 
3e1f52eb-62b6-44c9-b3bb-afb483e1ab39 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.19 
810ec8c4-970b-43e3-967f-efa792253520 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.2  
8d8dfcdd-0292-461c-8e93-0bd4ee3e3856 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.20 
75151e88-0520-4d0f-8fae-fd0b3fe4d779 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.21 
62e7fa43-7186-4003-8e41-d4784a8ef9a3 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.22 
ba335b80-e0d4-47a1-b048-6dad5a88c4a1 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.23 
c311cedd-fef8-4d5c-8d6e-4d124468a041 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.24 
8d24838d-75c8-488f-9d99-719f4ecf4b41 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.25 
7d0d4949-df27-4d49-b6d3-bf6583009f52 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.26 
00c0db67-aa6c-4a2b-80db-49cc1c13dcce | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.27 
6559582b-0157-4946-adf0-6cbb4d82f414 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.28 
8f3f7b8e-2391-41de-a0ff-f68ddd7e3c7f | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.29 
f7a3fd46-fce0-4270-91e7-5501b1c35a97 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.3  
d16b33f9-bdb9-4de5-b23d-17989a61d38e | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.30 
863407d8-7ba9-4fce-9215-53b8db809bd1 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.4  
1376d2d6-a3ff-4801-9b1a-610a5bed8f76 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.5  
5aafd858-3b11-46a5-9ef5-0b90aaea72b9 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.6  
48ecc21a-9a2f-4d28-9752-7048e1624df0 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.7  
5859e4ea-2469-460e-bc34-3ed1a30d963d | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.8  
e2af0a44-f851-4b9d-87ae-aab947b22c0f | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.1.9  
874b4199-7969-4a27-aa7c-c4272d4a0216 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.2.0  
cbda1d97-7235-425b-8e51-e6f7c850cfde | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.2.1  
4324e9d1-214d-4b5d-ab8f-077760199d09 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.2.2  
0ef6cc2a-fc65-451f-91f6-4bdc4ee3411a | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.2.3  
d16e6180-3344-415c-bb7b-4d3189bcefb3 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.2.4  
5d2e6dac-7c50-4312-b8a8-d991a42cffe8 | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.2.5  
4638a6e8-2272-4971-82ce-64943bd4aa1d | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.2.6  
c6a3ec78-3e3a-4e77-9bbe-e7861e14a72b | <NAME > | <AUTH> | 0.2.7  
-------------------------------------|---------|--------|--------

Puppet modules use Semantic Versioning and we are following this standard for our in-house modules.

But hammer does not understand Semantic Versioning apparently:

0.1.2 < 0.1.10, yet 0.1.2 appears after 0.1.10 in the list

Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable):
6.1

How reproducible:
Each time the command is run

Steps to Reproduce:
1) Need a Satellite with many puppet mudules
2) run the following command:
hammer puppet-module list --organization ORGNAME --search "author:AUTHNAME AND name:NAME" --order "version"

Actual results:
The command result lines not sorted

Expected results:
The command result line sorted by version

Additional info:

Comment 3 Bryan Kearney 2016-08-04 20:10:15 UTC

Moving 6.2 bugs out to sat-backlog.

Comment 6 Bryan Kearney 2018-09-04 18:04:25 UTC

Thank you for your interest in Satellite 6. We have evaluated this request, and we do not expect this to be implemented in the product in the foreseeable future. We are therefore closing this out as WONTFIX. If you have any concerns about this, please feel free to contact Rich Jerrido or Bryan Kearney. Thank you.