Bug 2166879

Summary: DOS: loop of death created
Product: [Fedora] Fedora Reporter: customercare
Component: firefoxAssignee: Gecko Maintainer <gecko-bugs-nobody>
Status: NEW --- QA Contact: Fedora Extras Quality Assurance <extras-qa>
Severity: high Docs Contact:
Priority: unspecified    
Version: 38CC: erack, gecko-bugs-nobody, jhorak, klaas, pjasicek, rstrode, sandmann, stransky
Target Milestone: ---   
Target Release: ---   
Hardware: Unspecified   
OS: Unspecified   
Whiteboard:
Fixed In Version: Doc Type: If docs needed, set a value
Doc Text:
Story Points: ---
Clone Of: Environment:
Last Closed: Type: Bug
Regression: --- Mount Type: ---
Documentation: --- CRM:
Verified Versions: Category: ---
oVirt Team: --- RHEL 7.3 requirements from Atomic Host:
Cloudforms Team: --- Target Upstream Version:
Embargoed:

Description customercare 2023-02-03 10:41:03 UTC
Description of problem:

I detected a "loop of death" inside firefox+DE, which can OOM firefox with a possible crash in the end.

Of course this is a level 8 problem, as the user selects this. The real bug is, that ff offers itself as the app to handle this. This should not happen.

Additionally, FF does not seem to detect, that it is inside this loop of opening files via the DEs Default App function. I suggest to add one, as this leeds to OOM (takes a while), crash&db-corruption(due to oom) and waste of diskspace (partfile entries). 

In my test, i stopped it at 453 tabs + partfiles :)

Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable):

ALL

How reproducible:

easy.

Opening an MD file, like Readme.md, with firefox.


Steps to Reproduce:

1. Find a Markdown file
2. open it with firefox
3. Firefox offers to download that md file ( pre-selected ) or to open it in an App. Select firefox. Loop closed.

Now we have a loop of opening tabs on our hands, which produces PART Files in the userhome:

-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 WFNDAxzY.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 wjf954Ez.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 wKlezHso.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:11 wMpPLySE.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 WpxVeW8E.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 wQOo8Du2.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 wtPT_gBB.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 WvxNyIlJ.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 wVXwqzS9.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 WxinqAhW.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 -wXmm0fo.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 wZsHjXgz.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 X8uzLaFy.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 xczNf5T_.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 Xd8d8zjF.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 xd-rAjTh.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 xHA9FPof.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:11 XiwxZ6Lr.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 xIY7YT6p.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 XOjfitdK.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 XOLeojyL.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 xoxbEngL.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 XpFmDscK.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 xPqzoCDy.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 XsqD-MxM.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 Xt_EQNsx.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 XyHDZfcv.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 xYlPzOcg.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 Xyz8MFoB.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 Y0793--B.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:11 Y33prt5r.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 Y3n4Jlao.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 y5gqxvp-.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 y7BJ7rr3.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 Y7D6kAdU.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 y7QlpRyx.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:11 YclFs4fm.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:11 ygSiiVET.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 yiWa5DWq.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:11 YM7AnK4R.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 yMS61vWE.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 _Yprvz6d.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:11 YPSOm_ZN.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 Y-sao3NZ.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 ysW8XkfW.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 yuFleI0H.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 yUSdxFSK.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 yXyvb-rp.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:11 yzrvwC1B.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 z9vRmjrj.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 ZehVT_gf.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 ZfILuE4u.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 zgyhWqXf.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 ZHUcPSoX.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 zlexJF1a.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 z_NFNQjP.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 zuAd-gQ4.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 ZvkM9XCi.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 zvvUbOD_.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:11 zVXxj9Tz.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:11 zxmOuI3i.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:10 zY8ReQS4.part
-rw-------. 1 username username 0  3. Feb 11:11 _ZzGApIf.part

Comment 1 customercare 2023-02-03 10:42:56 UTC
sidenote: it was not possible to use any other app, as any new tab focused firefox. The window context menu was the only way to end FF.

Comment 2 Ben Cotton 2023-02-07 15:08:02 UTC
This bug appears to have been reported against 'rawhide' during the Fedora Linux 38 development cycle.
Changing version to 38.

Comment 3 customercare 2023-08-10 16:15:19 UTC
6 months and no reaction at all :(

Comment 4 Martin Stransky 2023-08-10 19:24:58 UTC
(In reply to customercare from comment #3)
> 6 months and no reaction at all :(

Sorry, I have no idea how to handle it.