Created attachment 1198771 [details]
run_jsvc.sh

Description of problem:

Customer would like to use jsvc with JBoss EAP 6 for binding to port 80 and 443 as non-root user. Testing was done using jboss-eap-6.4.0-installer.jar to install jboss 6.4.0, with openjdk and sun jdk and also jboss 6.4.7 with sun jdk only. All the tests failed with the following exception, JBoss was not able to start at port 80 with jsvc:
============================ error message =============================
13:48:32,944 ERROR [org.apache.coyote.http11.Http11Protocol] (MSC service thread 1-3) JBWEB003043: Error initializing endpoint: java.net.BindException: Permission denied /127.0.0.1:80
========================================================================

Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable):

jsvc 1.0.15 DR1 

How reproducible:

Always

Steps to Reproduce:

1) change JBoss http port to 80 using CLI
2) create run_jsvc.sh for starting JBoss using jsvc (see attached)
3) execute run_jsvc.sh as root, expecting to see JBoss running binding to port with user jboss

Actual results:

Error initializing endpoint: java.net.BindException: Permission denied /127.0.0.1:80

Expected results:

JBoss running as user jboss without errors

Additional info:

Tom has the following comments

Created By: Tom Fonteyne  (07/09/2016 13:08)
[private]

http://git.app.eng.bos.redhat.com/git/apache/commons-daemon.git/

only has one branch, and no tags.

checkout remotes/origin/1.0.15.redhat

then:

commons-daemon/src/native/unix/native/jsvc-unix.c

line 832:

    /* Load the service */
    if (java_load(args) != true) {
        log_debug("java_load failed");
        return 3;
    }
    else
        log_debug("java_load done");

    /* Downgrade user */
#ifdef OS_LINUX
    if (args->user && set_caps(0) != 0) {
        log_debug("set_caps (0) failed");
        return 4;
    }
#else
    if (set_user_group(args->user, uid, gid) != 0)
        return 4;
#endif

    /* Start the service */
    umask(envmask);
    if (java_start() != true) {
        log_debug("java_start failed");
        return 5;
    }
    else
        log_debug("java_start done");
...

So Java gets loaded, capabilities get withdrawn, java starts.

Double check "/proc/<pid>/status   and its easy to see that the capabilities have not been inherited.

Test 1: remove the set_cap(0)
=> port 80 works (obviously)
=> /proc/<pid>/status   shows that the process still has the caps set (again, obviously) => not good as not secure.

Solution:

    /* Load the service */
    if (java_load(args) != true) {
        log_debug("java_load failed");
        return 3;
    }
    else
        log_debug("java_load done");

    /* Start the service */
    umask(envmask);
    if (java_start() != true) {
        log_debug("java_start failed");
        return 5;
    }
    else
        log_debug("java_start done");

    /* Downgrade user */
#ifdef OS_LINUX
    if (args->user && set_caps(0) != 0) {
        log_debug("set_caps (0) failed");
        return 4;
    }
#else
    if (set_user_group(args->user, uid, gid) != 0)
        return 4;
#endif

Now port 80 works, but more importantly /prov/<pid>/status   shows that the caps have been correctly/securely removed.


Note: there is no need to use the shell command "setcap" to modify jsvc or java itself !

Also note: rather obviously this still means you need to start jsvc as "root" with a "-user" setting to get EAP running as a non-root user.