Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 177686
Last modified: 2014-01-21 17:53:27 EST
Description of problem:
Software installation in Fedora Core is quite easy, even for a newbie, as long
as there is a rpm-package. But it is almost impossible to add a yum source for
the packages (given that there is a yum ressource provided).
To make it easier for the user user their could be a yum source file inside
the package, but that would broke the LSB and would not fit into
multi-distribution packages often provided by isvs for several different
distros (for example adobe wouldn't be able to provide one rpm for all
rpm-based distributions anymore).
The idea now is to create a meta-package which contains the rpm itself and the
needed data for a new repository file in /etc/yum.repos.d/*
Another option would be a meta package which just contains the repository data
and the name of the package which should be loaded from there.
- "external" software could kept up to date, too
- could be adopted by every isv with low effort
- could be implemented with low effort
- would work together with existing solutions
- would provide a solution to the update problem of isvs
- even if it is easy to implement, it ahs to be implemented
- it has to be adopted by isvs
A last advantage I see: if yum is enhanced once to login to and access
ssh/tls/howeversecured repositories (probably wanted by isvs), the information
about which access method and which login/pwd has to be transfered to the
user-computer somehow - that could be done with this file, too.
(And yes, I wanted to fill in a bug-enhancement report about the ability of
accessing repos with login methods, too, but I first wait what you think of
I'm not sure I understand what you're asking for, actually.
Do you want some easy way of adding more repositories in?
Yes, but without packing these information into a rpm package (because than
you wouldn't be able anymore to install this software on other rpm based
The reason why I ask for it: to take Adobe as an example again: if you
download and install their rpm pacakge, you have to take care for yourself if
you have to update their program because of security problems.
With the asked solution you wouldn't have to because you would already have
the repository activated in yum and as soon as their is a new version yum
would update automatically.
To add some notes about the aims I follow with this some wish:
Ubuntu targets the same aim (to add on third party packages easy; to add on
package "channels" easy) and tries to find ways to reach it:
Btw.: If no one likes this wish or if it is refused somewhere internally I
would like to close this bug.
Ok, here a real life example:
The ifolder server from Novell, now Open Source, is provided in a fedora core
But to install ifolder in the way it should work you need two steps:
1) You have to copy the repo file *manually* to /etc/yum.repos.d/* .
2) You have to install ifolder with the yum command line or with one of the
I think there should be an easy way to avoid having two steps, and to avoid
copying files as root manually, although it is "just" a wget.
You should have a kind of installer which first adds the repo file and then
invocates yum automatically to download and (!) install the corresponding
I know that this can be done with a special prepared rpm files (like the livna
repository package but with an additional "yum install xyz" script), but if
fedora wants isvs to use rpms therefore then there should be some kind of
We're working towards adding some functionality like this into the graphical
tools built around yum. It's not going to be something in base yum.