Description of problem: Thunderbird-lightning doesn't work with the new thunderbird Beta 3 that was just released. Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): 0.3.20090302hg.fc11 How reproducible: always Steps to Reproduce: 1. update thunderbird 2. 3. Actual results: Lightning doesn't work anymore Expected results: Lightning works. Additional info: The old thunderbird-lightning has both a min and max version of 3.0b2. We need a new one for 3.0b3....
Hmm, yup - would have thought 3.0b3 would have been tested against current lightning...
I can't use the existing data in my calender without the updated rpm. Thus I change the priority. Why aren't thunderbird et al built together?
For the record, you cannot do sudo yum erase thunderbird sudo yum install thunderbird-3.0-2.3.beta2.fc11.x86_64 thunderbird-lightning It breaks thunderbird.
(In reply to comment #2) > I can't use the existing data in my calender without the updated rpm. > Thus I change the priority. > Why aren't thunderbird et al built together? Because sunbird (and thunderbird-lightning) are not provided by Red Hat employees but by community and sometimes coordination doesn't work best.
(In reply to comment #4) > (In reply to comment #2) > > I can't use the existing data in my calender without the updated rpm. > > Thus I change the priority. > > Why aren't thunderbird et al built together? > > Because sunbird (and thunderbird-lightning) are not provided by Red Hat > employees but by community and sometimes coordination doesn't work best. No. It's 1.) because only Sunbird maintainer gets repoclosure e-mails, since it's its dependencies that broke, not Thunderbird, despite Thunderbird update broke the dependencies. 2.) The push scripts don't enforce that dependencies of updates are O.K. Therefore the Thunderbird maintainer is is not aware that he shouldn't push the update until the dependencies are fixed, the update system won't stop him. And I'm sometimes too slow to react, especially when the update is for a security issue and goes quickly directly into stable. However, the sunbird update was done a couple of days ago, closing this.
Created attachment 357629 [details] screenshot of thunderbird 3.0b3 I suppose the sunbird component is because there is no thunderbird-lightning component in the list. Lightning does not work.
Reopening.
Paolo: This is fixed in 0.5.20090302hg.fc11, you presumably have an older revision. You either need to wait for an update or grab it from the build system (koji).
(In reply to comment #6) > I suppose the sunbird component is because there is no thunderbird-lightning > component in the list. Lightning does not work. thunderbird-lightning is a binary subpackage of sunbird package. Try rpm -qi thunderbird-lightning and look at SourceRPM field.
I perfectly guess you can't check every extension before committing a new release of thunderbird, but lightning is becoming more and more a crucial component of thunderbird in professional environment (especially since it works well with outlook meeting requests). I did a fresh "yum clean all && yum update thunderbird-lightning" but no new release is available Anyway, injecting manually the latest Lightning nightly build form Mozilla website seems to work for my users but an updated packages would be even greater ;)
*** Bug 502496 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
(In reply to comment #10) > I perfectly guess you can't check every extension before committing a new > release of thunderbird, but lightning is becoming more and more a crucial > component of thunderbird in professional environment (especially since it > works well with outlook meeting requests). Well, it actually is possible. I was wrong claiming that thunderbird maintainer don't get mails for broken dependencies, nor that there was a broken dependency. In fact, the dependencies were done wrong in F11 (unlike rawhide) therefore there was not problem detected during repoclosure. Which means that scripts will detect such breakages in future and both maintainers of thunderbird and sunbird will be notified, so that incompatibilities can be avoided. > I did a fresh "yum clean all && yum update thunderbird-lightning" but no new > release is available > Anyway, injecting manually the latest Lightning nightly build form Mozilla > website seems to work for my users but an updated packages would be even > greater ;) There _is_ an update. Please read the bug before following up. For everyone that will run into this problem: There's an update created in the update system [1]. All we can do a this point is wait for it to get pushed. You can get the packages directly from the build system if you are in urge [2]. https://admin.fedoraproject.org/updates/sunbird-1.0-0.5.20090715hg.fc11 http://koji.fedoraproject.org/koji/buildinfo?buildID=127385
I detect a fair gnashing of teeth - thanks everyone for getting this out asap. Here's a direct link to the i586 package: http://kojipkgs.fedoraproject.org/packages/sunbird/1.0/0.5.20090715hg.fc11/i586/thunderbird-lightning-1.0-0.5.20090715hg.fc11.i586.rpm
1.0.0.5? 1.0.0.8 fc12 here and it doesn't work. Could you build the latest? 1.0.0.5 does let the calendar appear again on x96_64. thanks.
(In reply to comment #13) > I detect a fair gnashing of teeth - thanks everyone for getting this out asap. > > Here's a direct link to the i586 package: > http://kojipkgs.fedoraproject.org/packages/sunbird/1.0/0.5.20090715hg.fc11/i586/thunderbird-lightning-1.0-0.5.20090715hg.fc11.i586.rpm And the x86_64 package can be found here.... http://kojipkgs.fedoraproject.org/packages/sunbird/1.0/0.5.20090715hg.fc11/x86_64/thunderbird-lightning-1.0-0.5.20090715hg.fc11.x86_64.rpm