Bug 690261

Created attachment 487105 [details]
Script to reproduce bug.

Description of problem:

Scenerio is as follows:


Four brokers
  BrokerA1 :  (5671 in script)
  BrokerA2 : (5672 in script)
  BrokerB1 : (6671 in script)
  BrokerAB2: (6672 in script)


The federation is as follows 

qpid-route -d route add localhost:5671 localhost:5672 Bug '#.Key' 
qpid-route -d route add localhost:5672 localhost:5671 Bug '#.A.Key' 
qpid-route -d route add localhost:5672 localhost:5671 Bug '#.Other.Key' 

qpid-route -d route add localhost:6671 localhost:6672 Bug '#.Key' 
qpid-route -d route add localhost:6672 localhost:6671 Bug '#.B.Key' 
qpid-route -d route add localhost:6672 localhost:6671 Bug '#.Other.Key' 


BrokerA1->#.A.Key->BrokerA2
BrokerA1->#.Other.Key->BrokerA2
BrokerA1 <-#.Key <-BrokerA2


BrokerB1->#.B.Key->BrokerB2
BrokerB1->#.Other.Key->BrokerB2
BrokerB1 <-#.Key <-BrokerB2



Then the BrokerA1 and BrokerB1 are dynamically linked 

BrokerA1 <=> BrokerB1

The general flow is as follows:

Message(subject=B.Key) -> BrokerA2 -> BrokerA1 -> BrokerB1 -> BrokerB2 received
Message(subject=Other.Key) -> BrokerA2 -> BrokerA1 -> BrokerB1 -> BrokerB2(received)

Everything works perfectly, can send messages back and forth by pushing messages to brokers A2 or B2, the messages will arive on the opposite node.

So I put a message (with key A.Key or Other.Key) on A2, I can receive it on B2, and vice versa.


If I then terminate broker A1, wait any period of time and restart broker A1, wait any amount of time, and re run the above #.Key link works, but Other.Key does not.


My assumption is if the Static keys are the same, when the federation restarts it does not create the nessessary bindings if there is exists a route with the same name.





Additional info:
Once I put a drain on B1, things start working.