Description of problem: I am submitting this under selinux-policy as I can't see a generic selinux category or something specific to SELinux Alert Browser. Please file under correct category if I missed it. I searched bug database under SELinux alert, SELinux warning, and SElinux. The first two showed nothing, the third had a whole lot but nothing that I could decipher as being close to this. On F14 x86_64 using Gnome, I would get a pop-up when SELinux would issue a warning that I could then see in the SELinux Alert Browser (and could match up with what I saw in /var/log/audit/audit.log) In F16 i686 using Xfce, I do not get any clue that a warning has occurred and, when I bring up SELinux Troubleshooter to get the SELinux Alert Browser, it says there have been no warnings yet I can see them in /var/log/audit/audit.log. I suspect the lack of a pop-up has to do with it not thinking a warning has occurred. For testing, I am using my example from Bug 720223 in which I have a call to clamscan inside rc.local (the bug was incorrectly closed by me as I just discovered the warning in the log file today --- I am trying to reopen it). I have the call in a script so I can wrap it in a setenforce 0/1 to make errors into warnings (I tested without the wrapper awhile back and got same behavior for 720223 --- don't think such is an issue in this bug where its just Alert Browser not seeing warning in log file). Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): F14: uname: 2.6.35.14-106.fc14.x86_64 libselinux: 2.0.96-6.fc14.1 selinux-policy: 3.9.7-46.fc14 F16: uname: 3.1.9-1/fc16.i686 PAE libselinux: 2.1.6-5.fc16 selinux-policy: 3.10.0-71.fc16 How reproducible: 100% Steps to Reproduce: 1. on F16 machine, edit a marker tag into /var/log/audit/audit.log 2. cycle power or reboot 3. assuming you've put clamscan (or something else that will generate warnings) in the rc.local, you should be able to view /var/log/audit/audit.log and see those "avc: denied" warnings after your marker 4. bring up SELinux TroubleShooter and SELinux Alert Browser will indicate that there are no warnings Actual results: Warnings have occurred and I haven't been notified Expected results: Like F14, I should get a pop-up warning and, when looking in SELinux Alert Browser, I should see those warnings Additional info: I do not get any clamscan warnings if I run it as a cron job or directly execute as root ... the only place I see that bug is from a command inside rc.local (as in Bug 720223). It just so happens that using that bug as a test case displays this bug. I discovered this while trying to give more information for Bug 783364. I might have things not clearly separated between these two bugs and this new one that I am reporting ... please advise if I am doing a bad juggling job (smile) I put this as a "medium" as I haven't hit a situation where not knowing about a warning is important, but I could easily imagine a different usage where such would make the bug more important. Please let me know what more info I can give. If you want, I will send you an edited version of /var/log/audit/audit.log ... I just like to know what I need to send with it to show that SELinux Alert Browser doesn't think there have been any warnings as that seems to be problem. Thanks, Paul
*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of bug 782269 ***