Description of problem: When Migrating cron cartridge from v1 to v2 format, an error was seen during the migration executing: "Unable to find migrator for ..."(see the Actual results below). Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): Upgraded from devenv_345 to devenv_3200 How reproducible: Always Steps to Reproduce: 1. Launch a devenv-stage_345 ami 2. Create app with cron cartridge 3. scp -r ~/devenv-local and /etc/yum.repos.d/local.repo from devenv_3200 instance to same location on devenv-stage_345 instance 4. yum -y update --enablerepo devenv-local (This will upgrade devenv-stage_345 to devenv_3200) 5. oo-cart-version -c v2 6. rhc-v2-migrate --version 2.0.28 Actual results: When migrating cron, there was an error, see the log here: Migrating app 'zqdiy' gear 'zqdiy' with uuid '493694075307928059904000' on node 'ip-10-137-43-82' for user: zzhao Migrating gear on node with: /usr/bin/rhc-v2-migrate --login 'zzhao' --migrate-gear '493694075307928059904000' --app-name 'zqdiy' --version '2.0.28' Migrating on node... ***time_migrate_on_node_measured_from_broker=19485*** Migrate on node output: Beginning V1 -> V2 migration Marking step inspect_gear_state complete V1 stop lock not detected Marking step migrate_stop_lock complete Marking step stop_gear complete Marking step typeless_translated_vars complete Marking step gear_env_cleanup complete Migrating TMP to raw value Migrating HOME to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_REPO_DIR to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_METRICS_PORT to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_INTERNAL_PORT to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_APP_DNS to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_GEAR_DNS to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_HOMEDIR to raw value Migrating TMPDIR to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_APP_UUID to raw value Migrating HISTFILE to raw value Migrating TMP_DIR to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_DIY_PORT to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_DIY_IP to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_TMP_DIR to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_APP_NAME to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_INTERNAL_IP to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_GEAR_UUID to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_DATA_DIR to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_GEAR_NAME to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_METRICS_LOG_DIR to raw value Migrating PATH to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_METRICS_IP to raw value Migrating OPENSHIFT_DIY_LOG_DIR to raw value Marking step env_vars_to_raw complete Marking step cron_create_directory complete Marking step cron_setup complete Marking step cron_erb complete Unable to find migrator for <Cartridge: @manifest: {"Name"=>"cron", "Cartridge-Short-Name"=>"CRON", "Version"=>1.4, "Architecture"=>"noarch", "Display-Name"=>"Cron 1.4", "Description"=>"The Cron cartridge allows you to run command line programs at scheduled times. Use this for background jobs and periodic processing.", "License"=>"ASL 2.0", "License-Url"=>"http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0.txt", "Website"=>"http://www.openshift.com/", "Cartridge-Version"=>"0.0.1", "Cartridge-Vendor"=>"redhat", "Categories"=>["embedded"], "Help-Topics"=>{"Getting Started Guide"=>"https://www.openshift.com/blogs/getting-started-with-cron-jobs-on-openshift"}, "Provides"=>["cron-1.4", "cron", "scheduler-service", "cron-service"], "Publishes"=>{"get-job-listing"=>{"Type"=>"STRING:jobs"}}, "Subscribes"=>{"add-job"=>{"Type"=>"STRING:job"}, "remove-job"=>{"Type"=>"STRING:job"}}, "Scaling"=>{"Min"=>1, "Max"=>1}, "Install-Build-Required"=>false} @manifest_path: /var/lib/openshift/.cartridge_repository/redhat-cron/0.0.1/metadata/manifest.yml @version: 1.4 @cartridge_vendor: redhat @cartridge_version: 0.0.1 @name: cron @short_name: CRON @categories: ["embedded"] @is_deployable: false @is_web_proxy: false @install_build_required: false @directory: cron @repository_path: /var/lib/openshift/.cartridge_repository/redhat-cron/0.0.1 @endpoints: [] > Marking step cron_hook complete Marking step cron_connect_frontend complete Marking step metrics_create_directory complete Marking step metrics_setup complete Marking step metrics_erb complete applying metrics-0.1 migration post-process Moving contents of metrics-0.1/logs to metrics/logs Moving /var/lib/openshift/493694075307928059904000/metrics-0.1/logs/error_log-20130509-000000-EST Marking step metrics_hook complete Marking step metrics_connect_frontend complete Marking step diy_create_directory complete Marking step diy_setup complete Marking step diy_erb complete applying diy-0.1 migration post-process Moving contents of diy-0.1/logs to diy/logs Moving /var/lib/openshift/493694075307928059904000/diy-0.1/logs/server.log Marking step diy_hook complete Marking step diy_connect_frontend complete Pre-migration state: started Post-migration response code: 200 Leaving migration metadata in place due to problem detected with gear status Status: CLIENT_RESULT: cron scheduling service is enabled CLIENT_RESULT: Metrics is running CLIENT_RESULT: Application is running ***time_migrate_on_node_measured_from_node=19129*** ***time_redeploy_httpd_proxy=0*** ***time_restart=0*** ***time_total_migrate_gear_measured_from_broker=19510*** Expected results: The error is not expected Additional info: Giving a low severity since this app is migrated successfully although there is an error.
Sorry this feature didn't make it in till devenv_3201. Can you please try again on the latest.
This is still seen when upgrade devenv-stage_351 to devenv_3219 and migrate again. Steps: 1. Launch a devenv-stage_351 ami 2. Create app with cron cartridge(v1 format) 3. scp -r ~/devenv-local and /etc/yum.repos.d/local.repo from devenv_3219 instance to same location on devenv-stage_351 instance 4. yum -y update --enablerepo devenv-local 5. oo-cart-version -c v2 6. rhc-v2-migrate --version 2.0.28 When cron cartridge is being migrated, this message is still seen Unable to find migrator for <Cartridge: @manifest: {"Name"=>"cron", "Cartridge-Short-Name"=>"CRON", "Version"=>1.4, "Architecture"=>"noarch", "Display-Name"=>"Cron 1.4", "Description"=>"The Cron cartridge allows you to run command line programs at scheduled times. Use this for background jobs and periodic processing.", "License"=>"ASL 2.0", "License-Url"=>"http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0.txt", "Website"=>"http://www.openshift.com/", "Cartridge-Version"=>"0.0.1", "Cartridge-Vendor"=>"redhat", "Categories"=>["embedded"], "Help-Topics"=>{"Getting Started Guide"=>"https://www.openshift.com/blogs/getting-started-with-cron-jobs-on-openshift"}, "Provides"=>["cron-1.4", "cron", "scheduler-service", "cron-service"], "Publishes"=>{"get-job-listing"=>{"Type"=>"STRING:jobs"}}, "Subscribes"=>{"add-job"=>{"Type"=>"STRING:job"}, "remove-job"=>{"Type"=>"STRING:job"}}, "Scaling"=>{"Min"=>1, "Max"=>1}, "Install-Build-Required"=>false} @manifest_path: /var/lib/openshift/.cartridge_repository/redhat-cron/0.0.1/metadata/manifest.yml @version: 1.4 @cartridge_vendor: redhat @cartridge_version: 0.0.1 @name: cron @short_name: CRON @categories: ["embedded"] @is_deployable: false @is_web_proxy: false @install_build_required: false @directory: cron @repository_path: /var/lib/openshift/.cartridge_repository/redhat-cron/0.0.1 @endpoints: [] >
Again the fix wasn't in until 3201. Please try again with the latest.
Sorry about the last comment. I misread.
https://github.com/openshift/li/pull/1361
Commit pushed to master at https://github.com/openshift/li https://github.com/openshift/li/commit/7369b74753200b8f58d6ad3f9569d09eca0d369c Bug 961203
This is verified on devenv_3223 ........... Carts to migrate: ["cron-1.4", "php-5.3"] Migrating cartridge cron Marking step cron_create_directory complete Marking step cron_setup complete Marking step cron_erb complete applying cron-1.4 migration post-process Marking step cron_hook complete Marking step cron_reconfigure_git_repo complete Marking step cron_connect_frontend complete Migrating cartridge php Marking step php_create_directory complete Marking step php_setup complete Marking step php_erb complete applying php-5.3 migration post-process Moving contents of php-5.3/logs to php/logs Moving /var/lib/openshift/5191a24c33f82844dc000003/php-5.3/logs/error_log-20130514-000000-EST Moving contents of php-5.3/sessions to php/sessions Marking step php_hook complete Marking step php_reconfigure_git_repo complete Marking step php_connect_frontend complete Pre-migration state: started Post-migration response code: 200 Marking step validate_gear complete Cleaning up after migration***time_migrate_on_node_measured_from_node=57412*** ***time_redeploy_httpd_proxy=0*** ***time_restart=0*** ***time_total_migrate_gear_measured_from_broker=57591***