Description of problem: I added a non redhat vendored cart haproxy-status-api-0.1 and it's showing up on the client without vendor: dmcphers@mcpherson:/tmp/rhc$ rhc cartridge remove -a blah2 -c openshift-haproxy-status-api-0.1 -l danmcp6Short Name Full name ========== ========= haproxy-status-api-0.1 HAProxy Status API haproxy-1.4 OpenShift Web Balancer php-5.3 PHP 5.3 Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): How reproducible: Steps to Reproduce: 1. Add a non redhat cart 2. Try to reference it with the vendor name 3. Actual results: It doesn't use the cart with vendor name Expected results: It should only work with the vendor name Additional info:
fixed with rev#0188dd7a4cdbe6d837d174074789ebf11fa2c37c in origin-server.repo!
Verified it on devenv_3277: 1) After creating an app with vendor: xiaoliopenshift, cartidge_name:rubytest, it will be shown like following: #rhc app-show -a rubyapp --gears ID State Cartridges Size SSH URL ------------------------ ------- ---------------------------- ----- ------------------------------------------------------ 965961927916299290148864 started xiaoliopenshift-rubytest-1.9 small 965961927916299290148864.rhcloud.com 2) And added a custom mongodb and a redhat mysql to it: # rhc cartridge-add https://raw.github.com/xltian/mongotestonly/master/metadata/manifest.yml -a rubyapp It will list the non-redhat cartridge with vendor name but redhat cartridge without vendor name: # rhc app-show --gears -a rubyapp ID State Cartridges Size SSH URL ------------------------ ------- ------------------------------------------------------------------ ----- ------------------------------------------------------ 965961927916299290148864 started xiaoliopenshift-rubytest-1.9 openshiftxiaoli-mongodb-2.2 mysql-5.1 small 965961927916299290148864.rhcloud.com 3) Non-redhat cartridge could be referenced by with or without vendor name, if vendor name, related manifest file will not be listed, but redhat cartridge could only be referenced without vendor name. [root@ip-10-165-36-103 ~]# rhc cartridge restart -a rubyapp -c mongodb-2.2 The cartridge 'https://raw.github.com/xltian/mongotestonly/master/metadata/manifest.yml' will be downloaded and installed RESULT: openshiftxiaoli-mongodb-2.2 restarted [root@ip-10-165-36-103 ~]# rhc cartridge restart -a rubyapp -c openshiftxiaoli-mongodb-2.2 RESULT: openshiftxiaoli-mongodb-2.2 restarted [root@ip-10-165-36-103 ~]# rhc cartridge restart -a rubyapp -c mysql-5.1 RESULT: mysql-5.1 restarted [root@ip-10-165-36-103 ~]# rhc cartridge restart -a rubyapp -c redhat-mysql-5.1 Short Name Full name ========== ========= openshiftxiaoli-mongodb-2.2 MongoDB NoSQL Database 2.2 mysql-5.1 MySQL Database 5.1 xiaoliopenshift-rubytest-1.9 RubyTest 1.9 There are no cartridges that match 'redhat-mysql-5.1'. [root@ip-10-165-36-103 ~]# rhc cartridge restart -a rubyapp -c ruby The cartridge 'https://raw.github.com/xltian/rubytestonly/master/metadata/manifest.yml' will be downloaded and installed RESULT: xiaoliopenshift-rubytest-1.9 restarted [root@ip-10-165-36-103 ~]# rhc cartridge restart -a rubyapp -c xiaoliopenshift-rubytest-1.9 RESULT: xiaoliopenshift-rubytest-1.9 restarted Dan, Rajat: can you confirm if above are expected since current fix does not strictly match the expected result in the bug description? Thanks
What you describe is currently an expected client limitation. The restart of redhat-mysql-5.1 should work against the REST api as redhat-mysql-5.1 or mysql-5.1.
After bug 967409 is fixed, the vendor-name-version and name-version works now: # curl -k -H "Accept: application/xml" --user "xtian+t1:redhat" https://localhost/broker/rest/domains/domx1/applications/phpapp/cartridges/mysql-5.1/events -d event=restart -X POST <text>Added restart on mysql-5.1 for application phpapp</text> #curl -k -H "Accept: application/xml" --user "xtian+t1:redhat" https://localhost/broker/rest/domains/domx1/applications/phpapp/cartridges/redhat-mysql-5.1/events -d event=restart -X POST <text>Added restart on mysql-5.1 for application phpapp</text>