Bug 1163928

Summary: why runtime require gnome-icon-theme?
Product: [Fedora] Fedora Reporter: Wolfgang Ulbrich <raveit65.sun>
Component: system-config-printerAssignee: Tim Waugh <twaugh>
Status: CLOSED ERRATA QA Contact: Fedora Extras Quality Assurance <extras-qa>
Severity: unspecified Docs Contact:
Priority: unspecified    
Version: 21CC: grinnz, jpopelka, lnie, twaugh
Target Milestone: ---   
Target Release: ---   
Hardware: Unspecified   
OS: Unspecified   
Whiteboard:
Fixed In Version: system-config-printer-1.5.5-2.fc21 Doc Type: Bug Fix
Doc Text:
Story Points: ---
Clone Of: Environment:
Last Closed: 2015-02-22 06:02:58 UTC Type: Bug
Regression: --- Mount Type: ---
Documentation: --- CRM:
Verified Versions: Category: ---
oVirt Team: --- RHEL 7.3 requirements from Atomic Host:
Cloudforms Team: --- Target Upstream Version:
Embargoed:
Attachments:
Description Flags
adwaita theme
none
mate theme none

Description Wolfgang Ulbrich 2014-11-13 17:28:04 UTC 
Description of problem:
system-config-printer has a runtime require to gnome-icon-theme in spec file.
Is this really needed ?
It seems that gnome-icon-theme is obsolete and gnome use already adwaita-icon-theme.
Also gnome-shell has it own printer configuration, in result only desktops like mate, xfce, sugar, or lxde will use system-config-printer.
All this desktops has it own icon-themes, and use a icon-theme in their comps file to be shure that a icon-theme is installed.
So using 'Requires: gnome-icon-theme' or any other icon-theme is not really needed, imo.

The reason for why i ask is that i'm working on the mate-compiz live spin.
I added system-config-printer today and it pulls in gnome-icon-theme.
Which is pretty useless in Mate and increase only the size of the livecd, which i want to use for other applications.
Maybe this is fixable before we run in release freeze and installer images are tag for release.

Correct if i'm wrong, maybe you have a good reason to do that which i don't see.

Thank you
Comment 1 Tim Waugh 2014-11-13 18:21:39 UTC 
It needs to have certain named icons, e.g. i-network-printer, printer, emblem-pause, emblem-favorite.

Is adwaita-icon-theme a better requirement?
Comment 2 Wolfgang Ulbrich 2014-11-13 19:02:27 UTC 
Ok, for mate i would say we have this icons too, mate-icon-theme is a fork from gnome-icon-theme, but i don't know exactly the situation for other desktops.

adwaita-icon-theme should be a better requirement, because it is always installed.

a list of icons with printer in name.

[rave@mother icons]$ find Adwaita/ -name *printer*
Adwaita/22x22/devices/printer-network.png
Adwaita/22x22/devices/printer.png
Adwaita/22x22/status/printer-error.png
Adwaita/22x22/status/printer-printing.png
Adwaita/24x24/devices/printer-network-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/devices/printer-network.png
Adwaita/24x24/devices/printer-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/devices/printer.png
Adwaita/24x24/status/printer-error.png
Adwaita/24x24/status/printer-printing.png
Adwaita/24x24/status/printer-printing-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/status/printer-error-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/status/printer-warning-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/scalable/devices/printer-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/devices/printer-network-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/status/printer-error-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/status/printer-warning-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/status/printer-printing-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/16x16/devices/printer-network-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/devices/printer-network.png
Adwaita/16x16/devices/printer-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/devices/printer.png
Adwaita/16x16/status/printer-error.png
Adwaita/16x16/status/printer-printing.png
Adwaita/16x16/status/printer-printing-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/status/printer-error-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/status/printer-warning-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/devices/printer-network-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/devices/printer-network.png
Adwaita/32x32/devices/printer-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/devices/printer.png
Adwaita/32x32/status/printer-error.png
Adwaita/32x32/status/printer-printing.png
Adwaita/32x32/status/printer-printing-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/status/printer-error-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/status/printer-warning-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/256x256/devices/printer-network.png
Adwaita/256x256/devices/printer.png
Adwaita/256x256/status/printer-error.png
Adwaita/256x256/status/printer-printing.png
Adwaita/96x96/devices/printer-network-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/devices/printer-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/status/printer-printing-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/status/printer-error-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/status/printer-warning-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/devices/printer-network-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/devices/printer-network.png
Adwaita/48x48/devices/printer-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/devices/printer.png
Adwaita/48x48/status/printer-error.png
Adwaita/48x48/status/printer-printing.png
Adwaita/48x48/status/printer-printing-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/status/printer-error-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/status/printer-warning-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/devices/printer-network-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/devices/printer-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/status/printer-printing-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/status/printer-error-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/status/printer-warning-symbolic.symbolic.png

and emblems

Adwaita/22x22/emblems
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-photos.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-synchronizing.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-important.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-documents.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-default.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-unreadable.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-urgent.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-mail.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-downloads.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-web.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-favorite.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-shared.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-generic.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-symbolic-link.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-package.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-system.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-readonly.png
Adwaita/22x22/emblems/emblem-new.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-photos.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-synchronizing.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-important.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-documents.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-default.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-unreadable.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-photos-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-urgent.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-mail.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-favorite-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-shared-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-synchronizing-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-videos-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-downloads.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-web.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-favorite.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-music-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-system-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-default-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-shared.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-generic.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-ok-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-symbolic-link.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-documents-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-important-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-package.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-system.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-readonly.png
Adwaita/24x24/emblems/emblem-new.png
Adwaita/scalable/emblems
Adwaita/scalable/emblems/emblem-documents-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/emblems/emblem-videos-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/emblems/emblem-synchronizing-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/emblems/emblem-ok-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/emblems/emblem-system-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/emblems/emblem-shared-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/emblems/emblem-music-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/emblems/emblem-favorite-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/emblems/emblem-default-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/emblems/emblem-photos-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/scalable/emblems/emblem-important-symbolic.svg
Adwaita/16x16/emblems
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-photos.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-synchronizing.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-important.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-documents.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-default.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-unreadable.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-photos-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-urgent.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-mail.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-favorite-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-shared-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-synchronizing-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-videos-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-downloads.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-web.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-favorite.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-music-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-system-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-default-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-shared.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-generic.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-ok-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-symbolic-link.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-documents-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-important-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-package.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-system.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-readonly.png
Adwaita/16x16/emblems/emblem-new.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-photos.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-synchronizing.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-important.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-documents.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-default.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-unreadable.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-photos-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-urgent.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-mail.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-favorite-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-shared-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-synchronizing-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-videos-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-downloads.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-web.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-favorite.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-music-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-system-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-default-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-shared.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-generic.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-ok-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-symbolic-link.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-documents-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-important-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-package.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-system.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-readonly.png
Adwaita/32x32/emblems/emblem-new.png
Adwaita/256x256/emblems
Adwaita/256x256/emblems/emblem-synchronizing.png
Adwaita/256x256/emblems/emblem-unreadable.png
Adwaita/256x256/emblems/emblem-mail.png
Adwaita/256x256/emblems/emblem-shared.png
Adwaita/256x256/emblems/emblem-symbolic-link.png
Adwaita/256x256/emblems/emblem-package.png
Adwaita/256x256/emblems/emblem-readonly.png
Adwaita/8x8/emblems
Adwaita/8x8/emblems/emblem-synchronizing.png
Adwaita/8x8/emblems/emblem-default.png
Adwaita/8x8/emblems/emblem-unreadable.png
Adwaita/8x8/emblems/emblem-symbolic-link.png
Adwaita/8x8/emblems/emblem-readonly.png
Adwaita/8x8/emblems/emblem-new.png
Adwaita/96x96/emblems
Adwaita/96x96/emblems/emblem-photos-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/emblems/emblem-favorite-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/emblems/emblem-shared-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/emblems/emblem-synchronizing-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/emblems/emblem-videos-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/emblems/emblem-music-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/emblems/emblem-system-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/emblems/emblem-default-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/emblems/emblem-ok-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/emblems/emblem-documents-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/96x96/emblems/emblem-important-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-photos.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-synchronizing.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-important.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-documents.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-default.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-unreadable.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-photos-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-urgent.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-mail.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-favorite-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-shared-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-synchronizing-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-videos-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-downloads.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-web.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-favorite.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-music-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-system-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-default-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-shared.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-generic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-ok-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-symbolic-link.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-documents-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-important-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-package.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-system.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-readonly.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-desktop.png
Adwaita/48x48/emblems/emblem-new.png
Adwaita/64x64/emblems
Adwaita/64x64/emblems/emblem-photos-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/emblems/emblem-favorite-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/emblems/emblem-shared-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/emblems/emblem-synchronizing-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/emblems/emblem-videos-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/emblems/emblem-music-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/emblems/emblem-system-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/emblems/emblem-default-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/emblems/emblem-ok-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/emblems/emblem-documents-symbolic.symbolic.png
Adwaita/64x64/emblems/emblem-important-symbolic.symbolic.png

Another solution could be to check if gnome-icon-theme-legacy is sufficient.
Comment 3 Wolfgang Ulbrich 2014-11-13 19:11:26 UTC 
a quick test shows that no icons are missing with adwaita-icon-theme or mate-icon-theme
Comment 4 Wolfgang Ulbrich 2014-11-13 19:12:23 UTC 
Created attachment 957276 [details]
adwaita theme
Comment 5 Wolfgang Ulbrich 2014-11-13 19:13:07 UTC 
Created attachment 957277 [details]
mate theme
Comment 6 Tim Waugh 2014-11-14 09:29:27 UTC 
I think this needs more investigation into exactly which names system-config-printer ought to be using, and whether they are Gtk.STOCK_*-type names or literal strings.
Comment 7 Wolfgang Ulbrich 2014-11-14 09:48:16 UTC 
Ok, if you give me a list i can check it against posible themes.
Comment 8 Fedora Update System 2015-02-06 20:44:30 UTC 
system-config-printer-1.5.5-1.fc21 has been submitted as an update for Fedora 21.
https://admin.fedoraproject.org/updates/system-config-printer-1.5.5-1.fc21
Comment 9 Fedora Update System 2015-02-09 05:26:30 UTC 
Package system-config-printer-1.5.5-2.fc21:
* should fix your issue,
* was pushed to the Fedora 21 testing repository,
* should be available at your local mirror within two days.
Update it with:
# su -c 'yum update --enablerepo=updates-testing system-config-printer-1.5.5-2.fc21'
as soon as you are able to.
Please go to the following url:
https://admin.fedoraproject.org/updates/FEDORA-2015-1876/system-config-printer-1.5.5-2.fc21
then log in and leave karma (feedback).
Comment 10 lnie 2015-02-09 05:55:55 UTC 
system-config-printer-1.5.5-1.fc21 works
Comment 11 Fedora Update System 2015-02-22 06:02:58 UTC 
system-config-printer-1.5.5-2.fc21 has been pushed to the Fedora 21 stable repository.  If problems still persist, please make note of it in this bug report.