Bug 1278196

Can you attach the debugdata [1] (one for `dnf upgrade plasma-workspace --assumeno` and another for `dnf upgrade plasma-workspace --assumeno --setopt=install_weak_deps=0`, please?

[1] https://github.com/rpm-software-management/dnf/wiki/Bug-Reporting#dependency-resolution-problem

I will attach it with next plasma-workspace update.

Created attachment 1093415 [details]
debugdata

# rpm -q libsolv hawkey dnf
libsolv-0.6.14-2.fc24.i686
hawkey-0.6.2-1.fc24.i686
dnf-1.1.3-1.fc24.noarch

# dnf upgrade plasma-workspace --assumeno --debugsolver 
cachedir: /var/cache/dnf
Loaded plugins: needs-restarting, playground, config-manager, download, debuginfo-install, generate_completion_cache, noroot, protected_packages, copr, Query, reposync, builddep
DNF version: 1.1.3
repo: using cache for: rawhide
not found updateinfo for: Fedora - Rawhide - Developmental packages for the next Fedora release
repo: using cache for: adobe-linux-i386
not found deltainfo for: Adobe Systems Incorporated
not found updateinfo for: Adobe Systems Incorporated
repo: using cache for: russianfedora-free-rawhide
not found deltainfo for: Russian Fedora for Fedora Rawhide - Free
not found updateinfo for: Russian Fedora for Fedora Rawhide - Free
repo: using cache for: rpmfusion-free-rawhide
not found deltainfo for: RPM Fusion for Fedora Rawhide - Free
not found updateinfo for: RPM Fusion for Fedora Rawhide - Free
rawhide: using metadata from Thu Nov 12 09:12:34 2015.
adobe-linux-i386: using metadata from Tue Nov  3 21:05:52 2015.
russianfedora-free-rawhide: using metadata from Thu Nov 12 11:40:34 2015.
rpmfusion-free-rawhide: using metadata from Mon Jul  6 17:04:24 2015.
Last metadata expiration check performed 0:10:35 ago on Thu Nov 12 19:21:07 2015.
--> Starting dependency resolution
---> Package plasma-workspace-geolocation.i686 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be installed
---> Package kf5-networkmanager-qt.i686 5.16.0-1.fc24 will be installed
---> Package plasma-workspace-geolocation-libs.i686 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be installed
---> Package NetworkManager.i686 1:1.2.0-0.3.20151023gite01c175.fc24 will be installed
---> Package libndp.i686 1.5-2.fc23 will be installed
---> Package NetworkManager-libnm.i686 1:1.2.0-0.3.20151023gite01c175.fc24 will be installed
---> Package plasma-workspace.i686 5.4.3-1.fc24 will be upgraded
---> Package plasma-workspace.i686 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be an upgrade
---> Package libkworkspace5.i686 5.4.3-1.fc24 will be upgraded
---> Package libkworkspace5.i686 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be an upgrade
---> Package plasma-workspace-common.i686 5.4.3-1.fc24 will be upgraded
---> Package plasma-workspace-common.i686 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be an upgrade
---> Package plasma-workspace-libs.i686 5.4.3-1.fc24 will be upgraded
---> Package plasma-workspace-libs.i686 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be an upgrade
---> Package sddm-breeze.noarch 5.4.3-1.fc24 will be upgraded
---> Package sddm-breeze.noarch 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be an upgrade
---> Package plasma-workspace-drkonqi.i686 5.4.3-1.fc24 will be upgraded
---> Package plasma-workspace-drkonqi.i686 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be an upgrade
--> Finished dependency resolution
Dependencies resolved.
=======================================================================================================
 Package                             Arch     Version                                  Repository
                                                                                                  Size
=======================================================================================================
Installing:
 NetworkManager                      i686     1:1.2.0-0.3.20151023gite01c175.fc24      rawhide   2.4 M
 NetworkManager-libnm                i686     1:1.2.0-0.3.20151023gite01c175.fc24      rawhide   509 k
 kf5-networkmanager-qt               i686     5.16.0-1.fc24                            rawhide   353 k
 libndp                              i686     1.5-2.fc23                               rawhide    35 k
 plasma-workspace-geolocation        i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide    59 k
 plasma-workspace-geolocation-libs   i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide    29 k
Upgrading:
 libkworkspace5                      i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide    89 k
 plasma-workspace                    i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide    10 M
 plasma-workspace-common             i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide    29 k
 plasma-workspace-drkonqi            i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide   818 k
 plasma-workspace-libs               i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide   280 k
 sddm-breeze                         noarch   5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide   2.4 M

Transaction Summary
=======================================================================================================
Install  6 Packages
Upgrade  6 Packages

Total download size: 17 M
Operation aborted.

Created attachment 1093416 [details]
debugdata

# dnf upgrade plasma-workspace --assumeno --setopt=install_weak_deps=0 --debugsolver
cachedir: /var/cache/dnf
Loaded plugins: needs-restarting, noroot, playground, config-manager, protected_packages, reposync, download, generate_completion_cache, copr, Query, debuginfo-install, builddep
DNF version: 1.1.3
repo: using cache for: adobe-linux-i386
not found deltainfo for: Adobe Systems Incorporated
not found updateinfo for: Adobe Systems Incorporated
repo: using cache for: rpmfusion-free-rawhide
not found deltainfo for: RPM Fusion for Fedora Rawhide - Free
not found updateinfo for: RPM Fusion for Fedora Rawhide - Free
repo: using cache for: russianfedora-free-rawhide
not found deltainfo for: Russian Fedora for Fedora Rawhide - Free
not found updateinfo for: Russian Fedora for Fedora Rawhide - Free
repo: using cache for: rawhide
not found updateinfo for: Fedora - Rawhide - Developmental packages for the next Fedora release
adobe-linux-i386: using metadata from Tue Nov  3 21:05:52 2015.
rpmfusion-free-rawhide: using metadata from Mon Jul  6 17:04:24 2015.
russianfedora-free-rawhide: using metadata from Thu Nov 12 11:40:34 2015.
rawhide: using metadata from Thu Nov 12 09:12:34 2015.
Last metadata expiration check performed 0:23:02 ago on Thu Nov 12 19:21:07 2015.
--> Starting dependency resolution
---> Package plasma-workspace.i686 5.4.3-1.fc24 will be upgraded
---> Package plasma-workspace.i686 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be an upgrade
---> Package libkworkspace5.i686 5.4.3-1.fc24 will be upgraded
---> Package libkworkspace5.i686 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be an upgrade
---> Package plasma-workspace-common.i686 5.4.3-1.fc24 will be upgraded
---> Package plasma-workspace-common.i686 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be an upgrade
---> Package plasma-workspace-libs.i686 5.4.3-1.fc24 will be upgraded
---> Package plasma-workspace-libs.i686 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be an upgrade
---> Package sddm-breeze.noarch 5.4.3-1.fc24 will be upgraded
---> Package sddm-breeze.noarch 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be an upgrade
---> Package plasma-workspace-drkonqi.i686 5.4.3-1.fc24 will be upgraded
---> Package plasma-workspace-drkonqi.i686 5.4.3-2.fc24 will be an upgrade
--> Finished dependency resolution
Dependencies resolved.
=======================================================================================================
 Package                             Arch     Version                                  Repository
                                                                                                  Size
=======================================================================================================
Upgrading:
 libkworkspace5                      i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide    89 k
 plasma-workspace                    i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide    10 M
 plasma-workspace-common             i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide    29 k
 plasma-workspace-drkonqi            i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide   818 k
 plasma-workspace-libs               i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide   280 k
 sddm-breeze                         noarch   5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide   2.4 M
Skipping packages with conflicts:
(add '--best --allowerasing' to command line to force their upgrade):
 NetworkManager                      i686     1:1.2.0-0.3.20151023gite01c175.fc24      rawhide   2.4 M
 NetworkManager-libnm                i686     1:1.2.0-0.3.20151023gite01c175.fc24      rawhide   509 k
 kf5-networkmanager-qt               i686     5.16.0-1.fc24                            rawhide   353 k
 libndp                              i686     1.5-2.fc23                               rawhide    35 k
 plasma-workspace-geolocation        i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide    59 k
 plasma-workspace-geolocation-libs   i686     5.4.3-2.fc24                             rawhide    29 k

Transaction Summary
=======================================================================================================
Upgrade  6 Packages

Total download size: 14 M
Operation aborted.

This bug appears to have been reported against 'rawhide' during the Fedora 24 development cycle.
Changing version to '24'.

More information and reason for this action is here:
https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Fedora_Program_Management/HouseKeeping/Fedora24#Rawhide_Rebase

This package has changed ownership in the Fedora Package Database.  Reassigning to the new owner of this component.

Is it still reproducible?

(In reply to Igor Gnatenko from comment #7)
> Is it still reproducible?

Yes, I just got it with a setup where I had gnutls-3.4.15-1.fc24.x86_64 and its trousers* weak dep NOT installed.


# rpm -q dnf
dnf-1.1.10-1.fc24.noarch

# rpm -qa "trousers*"
(nothing)


Problem 1; debatable, I suppose): pulls in weak deps on upgrade:

# dnf upgrade
========================================================================
 Package            Arch      Version                  Repository  Size
========================================================================
Installing:
 trousers           x86_64    0.3.13-6.fc24            fedora     150 k
 trousers-lib       x86_64    0.3.13-6.fc24            fedora     157 k
Upgrading:
 ca-certificates    noarch    2016.2.10-1.0.fc24       updates    425 k
 gnutls             x86_64    3.4.16-1.fc24            updates    660 k


Problem 2; clearly a wrong message about conflicts:

# dnf --setopt install_weak_deps=False upgrade
========================================================================
 Package            Arch      Version                  Repository  Size
========================================================================
Upgrading:
 ca-certificates    noarch    2016.2.10-1.0.fc24       updates    425 k
 gnutls             x86_64    3.4.16-1.fc24            updates    660 k
Skipping packages with conflicts:
(add '--best --allowerasing' to command line to force their upgrade):
 trousers           x86_64    0.3.13-6.fc24            fedora     150 k
 trousers-lib       x86_64    0.3.13-6.fc24            fedora     157 k

*** Bug 1346681 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

The question why we install weak-deps for install command by default? We can do, that for upgrade command we will ignore install_weak_deps.

I created a patch that should help: https://github.com/rpm-software-management/dnf/pull/774

The issue from Comment 8 is still valid (in commad "dnf --setopt install_weak_deps=False upgrade"), but it is reported in another bug report.

I have tried to fix the issue, but during discussion it appears that proper solution will be too difficult to implement according to requirement of selective handling of weak-deps. Therefore I have to to close it as deferred, therefore in future we can reopen it when we will have a possibility to solve such a complex tasks.