Bug 1283041

Summary: DNF thinks a group is installed even though its packages has been removed
Product: [Fedora] Fedora Reporter: Sudhir Khanger <sudhir>
Component: dnfAssignee: Packaging Maintenance Team <packaging-team-maint>
Status: CLOSED NOTABUG QA Contact: Fedora Extras Quality Assurance <extras-qa>
Severity: unspecified Docs Contact:
Priority: unspecified    
Version: 22CC: jsilhan, mluscon, packaging-team-maint, pnemade, vmukhame
Target Milestone: ---   
Target Release: ---   
Hardware: Unspecified   
OS: Unspecified   
Fixed In Version: Doc Type: Bug Fix
Doc Text:
Story Points: ---
Clone Of: Environment:
Last Closed: 2015-12-02 10:35:00 UTC Type: Bug
Regression: --- Mount Type: ---
Documentation: --- CRM:
Verified Versions: Category: ---
oVirt Team: --- RHEL 7.3 requirements from Atomic Host:
Cloudforms Team: ---

Description Sudhir Khanger 2015-11-18 05:16:05 UTC
Description of problem:
I installed lxqt group via dnf group install lxqt. I wanted to remove lxqt group but sadly dnf wanted to remove packages worth 700mb which included all of KDE and other applications. It even included packages that were not explicitly installed by me. So I removed the packages that dnf group install lxqt installed. I have no lxqt but I can no longer install lxqt group anymore because dnf thinks lxqt is installed.

Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): dnf-1.1.3-1.fc22.noarch

How reproducible:

Steps to Reproduce:
1. dnf group install lxqt
2. dnf remove (remove packages installed by the lxqt group)
3. dnf group install lxqt

Actual results:
when you run dnf group install lxqt it will tell you that lxqt group in already installed. Although none of the packages from lxqt group are installed.

Expected results:
If packages in a group are missing and a user tries to install that group then that should install the missing packages. Also if all the packages from a group are missing then what's the point of misleading a user into believing that it is installed.

Additional info:

dnf group list

Last metadata expiration check performed 0:00:43 ago on Wed Nov 18 10:42:11 2015.
Available environment groups:
   Minimal Install
   Fedora Server
   Fedora Cloud Server
   KDE Plasma Workspaces
   Xfce Desktop
   LXDE Desktop
   Cinnamon Desktop
   MATE Desktop
   Sugar Desktop Environment
   Development and Creative Workstation
   Web Server
   Infrastructure Server
   Basic Desktop
Installed environment groups:
   Fedora Workstation
   LXQt Desktop
Installed groups:
   Administration Tools
   C Development Tools and Libraries

[sudhir@fedora ~]$ sudo dnf group install lxqt
[sudo] password for sudhir: 
Last metadata expiration check performed 1:09:21 ago on Wed Nov 18 09:34:08 2015.
Group 'LXQt' is already installed, skipping.
Dependencies resolved.
Nothing to do.
[sudhir@fedora ~]$ rpm -qa | grep lxqt
[sudhir@fedora ~]$

[sudhir@fedora ~]$ sudo dnf group remove lxqt
Last metadata expiration check performed 1:11:16 ago on Wed Nov 18 09:34:08 2015.
Dependencies resolved.
 Group                                Packages                                                                                                                        
Marking removed:
 LXQt                                 lxqt-about                                           lxqt-session                                         lxqt-runner           
                                      firewall-config                                      qupzilla                                             fedora-icon-theme     
                                      xdg-user-dirs                                        notification-daemon                                  lxqt-policykit        
                                      lxqt-common                                          oxygen-gtk2-theme                                    openbox               
                                      qterminal                                            lxqt-config                                          lxqt-globalkeys       
                                      lxqt-qtplugin                                        sddm                                                 initial-setup-gui     
                                      lxqt-panel                                           xarchiver                                            obconf                
                                      pcmanfm-qt                                           lxqt-notificationd                                   network-manager-applet
                                      lxqt-openssh-askpass                                 perl-File-MimeInfo                                   upower                
                                      nm-connection-editor                                 lxqt-powermanagement                                                       
 Package                                                  Arch                  Version                                           Repository                       Size
 accountsservice-libs                                     x86_64                0.6.40-1.fc22                                     @fedora                         298 k
 akregator                                                x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         2.5 M
 akregator-libs                                           x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         492 k
 apper                                                    x86_64                0.9.2-3.fc22                                      @updates                        4.1 M
 apr                                                      x86_64                1.5.1-3.fc22                                      @fedora                         231 k
 apr-util                                                 x86_64                1.5.4-1.fc22                                      @fedora                         194 k
 ark                                                      x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         623 k
 ark-libs                                                 x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         636 k
 audiocd-kio                                              x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         203 k
 audiocd-kio-libs                                         x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         188 k
 baloo-akonadi                                            x86_64                4.14.3-1.fc22                                     @System                         213 k
 baloo-libs                                               x86_64                4.14.3-1.fc22                                     @System                         853 k
 baloo-widgets                                            x86_64                4.14.3-1.fc22                                     @System                         232 k
 bijiben                                                  x86_64                3.16.2-1.fc22                                     @fedora                         1.2 M
 bluedevil                                                x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        1.8 M
 clutter-gst3                                             x86_64                3.0.14-1.fc22                                     @updates                        213 k
 colord-kde                                               x86_64                0.4.0-1.20150519git.fc22                          @System                         597 k
 control-center                                           x86_64                1:3.16.3-1.fc22                                   @updates                         17 M
 digikam                                                  x86_64                4.13.0-1.fc22                                     @updates                         37 M
 digikam-libs                                             x86_64                4.13.0-1.fc22                                     @updates                        7.7 M
 dleyna-connector-dbus                                    x86_64                0.2.0-4.fc22                                      @fedora                          43 k
 dleyna-core                                              x86_64                0.4.0-3.fc22                                      @fedora                          60 k
 dleyna-server                                            x86_64                0.4.0-7.fc22                                      @fedora                         188 k
 dolphin                                                  x86_64                15.04.3-2.fc22                                    @updates                        2.3 M
 dolphin-libs                                             x86_64                15.04.3-2.fc22                                    @updates                        1.0 M
 dragon                                                   x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         828 k
 evince-nautilus                                          x86_64                3.16.1-3.fc22                                     @updates                         19 k
 fedora-logos-httpd                                       noarch                22.0.0-1.fc22                                     @fedora                         4.6 k
 file-roller                                              x86_64                3.16.4-1.fc22                                     @updates                        3.8 M
 file-roller-nautilus                                     x86_64                3.16.4-1.fc22                                     @updates                         19 k
 firewall-config                                          noarch                                         @System                         783 k
 fuse-sshfs                                               x86_64                2.5-1.fc22                                        @fedora                         134 k
 gdm                                                      x86_64                1:3.16.3-1.fc22                                   @updates                        3.3 M
 gnome-bluetooth                                          x86_64                1:3.16.1-1.fc22                                   @fedora                          83 k
 gnome-bluetooth-libs                                     x86_64                1:3.16.1-1.fc22                                   @fedora                         2.1 M
 gnome-boxes                                              x86_64                3.16.2-4.fc22                                     @updates                        4.5 M
 gnome-classic-session                                    noarch                3.16.2-1.fc22                                     @updates                        114 k
 gnome-documents                                          x86_64                3.16.4-1.fc22                                     @updates                        1.9 M
 gnome-documents-libs                                     x86_64                3.16.4-1.fc22                                     @updates                        892 k
 gnome-icon-theme-legacy                                  noarch                3.12.0-2.fc21                                     @fedora                           0  
 gnome-initial-setup                                      x86_64                3.16.3-1.fc22                                     @fedora                         2.1 M
 gnome-keyring-pam                                        x86_64                3.16.0-1.fc22                                     @fedora                          44 k
 gnome-online-miners                                      x86_64                3.14.3-2.fc22                                     @updates                        328 k
 gnome-settings-daemon                                    x86_64                3.16.3-1.fc22                                     @updates                        5.6 M
 gnome-shell                                              x86_64                3.16.4-1.fc22                                     @updates                        9.2 M
 gnome-shell-extension-alternate-tab                      noarch                3.16.2-1.fc22                                     @updates                        9.4 k
 gnome-shell-extension-apps-menu                          noarch                3.16.2-1.fc22                                     @updates                         27 k
 gnome-shell-extension-background-logo                    noarch                3.16.1-1.fc22                                     @fedora                          56 k
 gnome-shell-extension-common                             noarch                3.16.2-1.fc22                                     @updates                        542 k
 gnome-shell-extension-gpaste                             noarch                                         @updates                         33 k
 gnome-shell-extension-launch-new-instance                noarch                3.16.2-1.fc22                                     @updates                        4.9 k
 gnome-shell-extension-places-menu                        noarch                3.16.2-1.fc22                                     @updates                         22 k
 gnome-shell-extension-user-theme                         noarch                3.16.2-1.fc22                                     @updates                        7.0 k
 gnome-shell-extension-window-list                        noarch                3.16.2-1.fc22                                     @updates                         55 k
 gnome-tweak-tool                                         noarch                3.16.2-1.fc22                                     @fedora                         941 k
 gnome-user-share                                         x86_64                3.14.2-1.fc22                                     @fedora                         467 k
 gom                                                      x86_64                0.3.1-1.fc22                                      @fedora                         205 k
 gpaste                                                   x86_64                                         @updates                        101 k
 gpaste-libs                                              x86_64                                         @updates                        354 k
 gpaste-ui                                                x86_64                                         @updates                         32 k
 grilo-plugins                                            x86_64                0.2.14-3.fc22                                     @updates                        1.5 M
 gwenview                                                 x86_64                4.14.3-4.fc22                                     @System                         3.1 M
 gwenview-libs                                            x86_64                4.14.3-4.fc22                                     @System                         1.3 M
 httpd                                                    x86_64                2.4.17-1.fc22                                     @updates                        6.0 M
 httpd-filesystem                                         noarch                2.4.17-1.fc22                                     @updates                        366  
 httpd-tools                                              x86_64                2.4.17-1.fc22                                     @updates                        177 k
 initial-setup-gui                                        x86_64                0.3.31-1.fc22                                     @System                          13 k
 juk                                                      x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @fedora                         1.8 M
 k3b                                                      x86_64                1:2.0.3-3.fc22                                    @System                         3.2 M
 k3b-common                                               noarch                1:2.0.3-3.fc22                                    @System                          22 M
 k3b-libs                                                 x86_64                1:2.0.3-3.fc22                                    @System                         6.4 M
 kaccounts-integration                                    x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         393 k
 kactivities-libs                                         x86_64                4.13.3-9.fc22                                     @System                         199 k
 kaddressbook                                             x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         477 k
 kaddressbook-libs                                        x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         1.1 M
 kamera                                                   x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         184 k
 kamoso                                                   x86_64                2.0.2-21.20140902git.fc22                         @System                         804 k
 kate4-part                                               x86_64                4.14.3-14.fc22                                    @System                         8.9 M
 kcalc                                                    x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         630 k
 kcharselect                                              x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         174 k
 kcm-gtk                                                  x86_64                0.5.3-16.fc22                                     @System                         133 k
 kcm_colors                                               x86_64                1:4.11.22-2.fc22                                  @updates                        255 k
 kcm_systemd                                              x86_64                1.2.1-1.fc22                                      @System                         779 k
 kcolorchooser                                            x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                          21 k
 kde-baseapps                                             x86_64                15.04.3-2.fc22                                    @updates                          0  
 kde-cli-tools                                            x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        3.4 M
 kde-connect                                              x86_64                0.8-9.fc22                                        @updates                        1.2 M
 kde-connect-libs                                         x86_64                0.8-9.fc22                                        @updates                        417 k
 kde-gtk-config                                           x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        662 k
 kde-partitionmanager                                     x86_64                1.2.1-3.fc22                                      @System                         7.4 M
 kde-platform-plugin                                      x86_64                1:4.11.22-2.fc22                                  @System                          49 k
 kde-print-manager                                        x86_64                15.03.95-2.fc22                                   @System                         764 k
 kde-print-manager-libs                                   x86_64                15.03.95-2.fc22                                   @System                         595 k
 kde-runtime                                              x86_64                15.08.2-1.fc22                                    @updates                         11 M
 kde-runtime-flags                                        noarch                15.08.2-1.fc22                                    @updates                        109 k
 kde-runtime-libs                                         x86_64                15.08.2-1.fc22                                    @updates                        5.4 M
 kde-settings                                             noarch                22-15.fc22                                        @updates                         78 k
 kde-settings-plasma                                      noarch                22-15.fc22                                        @updates                        3.2 k
 kde-settings-pulseaudio                                  noarch                22-15.fc22                                        @updates                          0  
 kde-style-breeze                                         x86_64                5.4.3-2.fc22                                      @updates                        522 k
 kdegraphics-thumbnailers                                 x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         129 k
 kdelibs                                                  x86_64                6:4.14.13-1.fc22                                  @updates                         42 M
 kdelibs-ktexteditor                                      x86_64                6:4.14.13-1.fc22                                  @updates                        272 k
 kdelibs-webkit                                           x86_64                6:4.14.13-1.fc22                                  @updates                        182 k
 kdepasswd                                                x86_64                15.04.3-2.fc22                                    @updates                        292 k
 kdepim-common                                            x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         1.8 M
 kdepim-libs                                              x86_64                7:4.14.9-1.fc22                                   @System                         8.9 M
 kdepim-runtime                                           x86_64                1:4.14.9-1.fc22                                   @System                          12 M
 kdepim-runtime-libs                                      x86_64                1:4.14.9-1.fc22                                   @System                         448 k
 kdepimlibs                                               x86_64                4.14.10-3.fc22                                    @updates                        8.5 M
 kdepimlibs-akonadi                                       x86_64                4.14.10-3.fc22                                    @updates                        6.7 M
 kdepimlibs-kxmlrpcclient                                 x86_64                4.14.10-3.fc22                                    @updates                         62 k
 kdeplasma-addons                                         x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        7.3 M
 kdesdk-thumbnailers                                      x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @fedora                          52 k
 kdesu                                                    x86_64                1:5.4.3-1.fc22                                    @updates                        113 k
 kdialog                                                  x86_64                15.04.3-2.fc22                                    @updates                        104 k
 kdnssd                                                   x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         106 k
 keditbookmarks                                           x86_64                15.04.3-2.fc22                                    @updates                        330 k
 keditbookmarks-libs                                      x86_64                15.04.3-2.fc22                                    @updates                        102 k
 kf5-baloo                                                x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                813 k
 kf5-baloo-file                                           x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                495 k
 kf5-baloo-libs                                           x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                485 k
 kf5-frameworkintegration                                 x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.9 M
 kf5-frameworkintegration-libs                            x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                 40 k
 kf5-kactivities                                          x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.0 M
 kf5-kactivities-libs                                     x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                664 k
 kf5-kbookmarks                                           x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                797 k
 kf5-kcmutils                                             x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.3 M
 kf5-kcompletion                                          x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                363 k
 kf5-kconfig-core                                         x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.0 M
 kf5-kconfig-gui                                          x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                134 k
 kf5-kconfigwidgets                                       x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.3 M
 kf5-kdeclarative                                         x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                973 k
 kf5-kded                                                 x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                155 k
 kf5-kdelibs4support                                      x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                 12 M
 kf5-kdelibs4support-libs                                 x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                3.0 M
 kf5-kdesu                                                x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                242 k
 kf5-kdewebkit                                            x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                209 k
 kf5-kemoticons                                           x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                416 k
 kf5-kglobalaccel                                         x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                202 k
 kf5-kglobalaccel-libs                                    x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                291 k
 kf5-khtml                                                x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                 12 M
 kf5-kiconthemes                                          x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                432 k
 kf5-kinit                                                x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                526 k
 kf5-kio-core                                             x86_64                5.16.0-2.fc22                                     @updates-testing                2.2 M
 kf5-kio-core-libs                                        x86_64                5.16.0-2.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.5 M
 kf5-kio-file-widgets                                     x86_64                5.16.0-2.fc22                                     @updates-testing                881 k
 kf5-kio-widgets                                          x86_64                5.16.0-2.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.4 M
 kf5-kio-widgets-libs                                     x86_64                5.16.0-2.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.3 M
 kf5-knewstuff                                            x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.9 M
 kf5-knotifications                                       x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                430 k
 kf5-knotifyconfig                                        x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                339 k
 kf5-kpackage                                             x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                660 k
 kf5-kparts                                               x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                695 k
 kf5-kpeople                                              x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                450 k
 kf5-kross-core                                           x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.0 M
 kf5-kross-ui                                             x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                775 k
 kf5-krunner                                              x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                229 k
 kf5-kservice                                             x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.0 M
 kf5-ktexteditor                                          x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                 13 M
 kf5-ktextwidgets                                         x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.3 M
 kf5-kwallet                                              x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                1.7 M
 kf5-kwallet-libs                                         x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                235 k
 kf5-kxmlgui                                              x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                3.4 M
 kf5-kxmlrpcclient                                        x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                124 k
 kf5-plasma                                               x86_64                5.16.0-1.fc22                                     @updates-testing                5.9 M
 kfilemetadata                                            x86_64                4.14.3-1.fc22                                     @System                         385 k
 kfind                                                    x86_64                15.04.3-2.fc22                                    @updates                        256 k
 kget                                                     x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         3.5 M
 kget-libs                                                x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         836 k
 kgpg                                                     x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         1.7 M
 khelpcenter                                              x86_64                1:5.4.3-1.fc22                                    @updates                        3.9 M
 khotkeys                                                 x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        2.4 M
 kinfocenter                                              x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        7.0 M
 kio-extras                                               x86_64                15.08.1-1.fc22                                    @System                         1.8 M
 kio-upnp-ms                                              x86_64                1.0.0-6.20111102git.fc22                          @System                         160 k
 kio_msits                                                x86_64                7:15.04.0-1.fc22                                  @System                          36 k
 kio_mtp                                                  x86_64                0.75-10.20141221gitc418634.fc22                   @System                         139 k
 kleopatra                                                x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         4.1 M
 kleopatra-libs                                           x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         1.7 M
 kmail                                                    x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         4.3 M
 kmail-libs                                               x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                          10 M
 kmenuedit                                                x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        1.3 M
 kmix                                                     x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         1.7 M
 knode                                                    x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         1.5 M
 knode-libs                                               x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         2.1 M
 knotes-libs                                              x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         511 k
 konqueror                                                x86_64                15.04.3-2.fc22                                    @updates                        6.2 M
 konqueror-libs                                           x86_64                15.04.3-2.fc22                                    @updates                        143 k
 konsole-part                                             x86_64                4.14.3-4.fc22                                     @System                         1.3 M
 konsole5                                                 x86_64                15.08.1-1.fc22                                    @System                         391 k
 konsole5-part                                            x86_64                15.08.1-1.fc22                                    @System                         1.5 M
 kontact                                                  x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         1.2 M
 kontact-libs                                             x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         217 k
 konversation                                             x86_64                1.6-1.fc22                                        @System                          14 M
 korganizer                                               x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         2.9 M
 korganizer-libs                                          x86_64                4.14.9-1.fc22                                     @System                         1.2 M
 kross-python                                             x86_64                4.14.3-1.fc22                                     @System                         403 k
 kruler                                                   x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         240 k
 kscreen                                                  x86_64                1:5.4.3-1.fc22                                    @updates                        743 k
 ksnapshot                                                x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         553 k
 ksshaskpass                                              x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                         91 k
 ksysguard                                                x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        2.5 M
 ktorrent                                                 x86_64                4.3.1-14.fc22                                     @System                          10 M
 ktorrent-libs                                            x86_64                4.3.1-14.fc22                                     @System                         551 k
 ktp-accounts-kcm                                         x86_64                15.04.2-3.fc22                                    @System                         654 k
 ktp-approver                                             x86_64                15.04.2-2.fc22                                    @System                         138 k
 ktp-auth-handler                                         x86_64                15.04.2-2.fc22                                    @System                         278 k
 ktp-common-internals                                     x86_64                15.04.2-3.fc22                                    @System                         2.5 M
 ktp-contact-list                                         x86_64                15.04.2-2.fc22                                    @System                         553 k
 ktp-filetransfer-handler                                 x86_64                15.04.2-2.fc22                                    @System                         171 k
 ktp-kded-integration-module                              x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         398 k
 ktp-send-file                                            x86_64                15.04.2-3.fc22                                    @System                          93 k
 ktp-text-ui                                              x86_64                15.04.2-3.fc22                                    @System                         2.4 M
 kuser                                                    x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         633 k
 kwalletmanager                                           x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         868 k
 kwalletmanager5                                          x86_64                15.04.0-1.20150501git.fc22                        @System                         990 k
 kwebkitpart                                              x86_64                1.3.4-5.fc22                                      @System                         1.1 M
 kwin                                                     x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                         13 M
 kwin-libs                                                x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        4.2 M
 kwrite                                                   x86_64                15.04.3-1.fc22                                    @System                         137 k
 kwrited                                                  x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                         63 k
 lensfun                                                  x86_64                0.3.0-6.fc22                                      @updates                        1.5 M
 libcue                                                   x86_64                1.4.0-4.fc21                                      @fedora                          87 k
 libfakekey                                               x86_64                0.1-13.fc22                                       @fedora                          28 k
 libgsf                                                   x86_64                1.14.33-1.fc22                                    @updates                        910 k
 libgsystem                                               x86_64                2015.1-2.fc22                                     @updates                         97 k
 libiptcdata                                              x86_64                1.0.4-12.fc22                                     @fedora                         159 k
 libkcddb                                                 x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         608 k
 libkcompactdisc                                          x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         178 k
 libkdcraw                                                x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         362 k
 libkdegames                                              x86_64                15.04.3-1.fc22                                    @System                          33 M
 libkdegames4                                             x86_64                14.12.3-10.fc22                                   @System                          33 M
 libkexiv2                                                x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         1.6 M
 libkface                                                 x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @fedora                          32 M
 libkfbapi                                                x86_64                1.0-4.fc22                                        @System                         530 k
 libkgapi                                                 x86_64                2.2.0-5.fc22                                      @System                         1.8 M
 libkgeomap                                               x86_64                15.04.0-2.fc22                                    @fedora                         490 k
 libkipi                                                  x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         273 k
 libkolab                                                 x86_64                0.5.3-1.fc22                                      @System                         949 k
 libkonq                                                  x86_64                15.04.3-2.fc22                                    @updates                        456 k
 libksane                                                 x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @fedora                         325 k
 libkscreen                                               x86_64                1:1.0.5-2.fc22                                    @System                         261 k
 libksysguard                                             x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        4.3 M
 libktorrent                                              x86_64                1.3.1-11.fc22                                     @System                         2.1 M
 libkworkspace                                            x86_64                1:4.11.22-2.fc22                                  @System                         151 k
 libkworkspace5                                           x86_64                5.4.3-2.fc22                                      @updates-testing                203 k
 liblqr-1                                                 x86_64                0.4.2-4.fc22                                      @fedora                         101 k
 libnghttp2                                               x86_64                1.2.1-1.fc22                                      @updates                        158 k
 libpgf                                                   x86_64                6.13.45-0.3.svn123.fc22                           @fedora                         106 k
 libreoffice-kde                                          x86_64                1:                                 @updates                        232 k
 libtunepimp                                              x86_64                0.5.3-26.fc22                                     @fedora                         964 k
 libvirt-gconfig                                          x86_64                0.2.1-1.fc22                                      @updates                        349 k
 libvirt-gobject                                          x86_64                0.2.1-1.fc22                                      @updates                        207 k
 libwacom                                                 x86_64                0.15-3.fc22                                       @updates                         82 k
 libwacom-data                                            noarch                0.15-3.fc22                                       @updates                        236 k
 libzapojit                                               x86_64                0.0.3-6.fc22                                      @fedora                         109 k
 marble-astro                                             x86_64                1:15.04.0-2.fc22                                  @fedora                         253 k
 marble-common                                            noarch                1:15.04.0-2.fc22                                  @fedora                          79 k
 marble-widget                                            x86_64                1:15.04.0-2.fc22                                  @fedora                         8.8 M
 marble-widget-data                                       noarch                1:15.04.0-2.fc22                                  @fedora                          23 M
 mod_dnssd                                                x86_64                0.6-12.fc22                                       @fedora                          53 k
 mutter                                                   x86_64                3.16.4-1.fc22                                     @updates                        5.2 M
 nautilus                                                 x86_64                3.16.2-2.fc22                                     @updates                         13 M
 nautilus-extensions                                      x86_64                3.16.2-2.fc22                                     @updates                         77 k
 okular                                                   x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         704 k
 okular-libs                                              x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         894 k
 okular-part                                              x86_64                15.04.0-1.fc22                                    @System                         3.2 M
 plasma-breeze                                            x86_64                5.4.3-2.fc22                                      @updates                        1.0 M
 plasma-desktop                                           x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                         29 M
 plasma-milou                                             x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        251 k
 plasma-nm                                                x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        3.7 M
 plasma-nm-l2tp                                           x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        238 k
 plasma-nm-openconnect                                    x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        235 k
 plasma-nm-openswan                                       x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        134 k
 plasma-nm-openvpn                                        x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        495 k
 plasma-nm-pptp                                           x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        192 k
 plasma-nm-vpnc                                           x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        349 k
 plasma-pa                                                x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        516 k
 plasma-pk-updates                                        x86_64                0.2-5.fc22                                        @updates                        152 k
 plasma-systemsettings                                    x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        946 k
 plasma-workspace                                         x86_64                5.4.3-2.fc22                                      @updates-testing                 31 M
 plasma-workspace-common                                  x86_64                5.4.3-2.fc22                                      @updates-testing                 44 k
 plasma-workspace-drkonqi                                 x86_64                5.4.3-2.fc22                                      @updates-testing                4.8 M
 plasma-workspace-geolocation                             x86_64                5.4.3-2.fc22                                      @updates-testing                138 k
 plasma-workspace-geolocation-libs                        x86_64                5.4.3-2.fc22                                      @updates-testing                 28 k
 plasma-workspace-libs                                    x86_64                5.4.3-2.fc22                                      @updates-testing                894 k
 polkit-kde                                               x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        254 k
 powerdevil                                               x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        2.0 M
 pulseaudio-gdm-hooks                                     x86_64                6.0-8.fc22                                        @updates                        354  
 qextserialport                                           x86_64                1.2-0.6.beta2.fc22                                @fedora                          81 k
 quazip                                                   x86_64                0.7.1-2.fc22                                      @fedora                         226 k
 sddm                                                     x86_64                0.12.0-5.fc22                                     @updates                        1.1 M
 sddm-breeze                                              noarch                5.4.3-2.fc22                                      @updates-testing                2.4 M
 sddm-kcm                                                 x86_64                5.4.3-1.fc22                                      @updates                        361 k
 shapelib                                                 x86_64                1.3.0f-5.fc22                                     @fedora                         173 k
 skanlite                                                 x86_64                1.1-3.fc22                                        @fedora                         2.8 M
 totem                                                    x86_64                1:3.16.4-1.fc22                                   @updates                        7.4 M
 totem-nautilus                                           x86_64                1:3.16.4-1.fc22                                   @updates                         32 k
 tracker                                                  x86_64                1.4.1-1.fc22                                      @updates                        5.2 M
 upower                                                   x86_64                0.99.3-1.fc22                                     @System                         423 k
 vino                                                     x86_64                3.16.0-1.fc22                                     @fedora                         2.0 M
 xdg-user-dirs                                            x86_64                0.15-4.fc22                                       @System                         163 k
 xdg-user-dirs-gtk                                        x86_64                0.10-6.fc22                                       @fedora                         193 k

Transaction Summary
Remove  304 Packages

Installed size: 774 M
Is this ok [y/N]: 
Operation aborted

Comment 1 Honza Silhan 2015-11-18 14:32:56 UTC
The bug is that during env group it should remove packages that belongs to that environment which was not installed by other installed group. Saying that your group is still installed is totally fine - you have removed the packages manually not by group command. You can type `dnf group mark remove lxqt` to mark the group as removed.

Comment 2 Sudhir Khanger 2015-11-18 14:46:19 UTC
Jan Zeleny in users mailing list suggested I use group mark and it worked perfectly. My apologies for not reading man pages properly.

I am not sure why `dnf group remove lxqt` wants to remove packages that are dependencies of KDE Plasma Desktop and Workstation. It even wants to remove some of the apps that I installed manually like JuK and gnome-shell-extension-gpaste. Why is removing lxqt group triggering removal of all installed desktop environments?

Please feel free to close the bug as the primary problem is not a bug.

Thank you.

Comment 3 Michal Luscon 2015-12-02 10:35:00 UTC
You probably hit https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1259865.

I am closing this one as a notabug.