Bug 356861

Relevant parts of /etc/gnokiirc are below:

[global]
port = /dev/ircomm0
model = AT
initlength = default
connection = irda
use_locking = no
serial_baudrate = 19200
smsc_timeout = 10

Oh, well, silly me, now I see it there: the correct model is AT not 6021. I
verified this by changing file /usr/share/gnome-phone-manager/phones.xml:

        <phone_entry
                identifier="Nokia 6021"
                driver="AT" />

With the above gnokiirc and the modified phones.xml g-p-m now works! And FWIW,
using AT in both configs was the only combination that worked.

So, please update the file /usr/share/gnome-phone-manager/phones.xml accordingly.

Sorry for the noise but I investigated this a bit more: in gnokii sources there
are these special drivers for Nokia models:

gnokii/common/phones/nk2110.c
gnokii/common/phones/nk3110.c
gnokii/common/phones/nk6100.c
gnokii/common/phones/nk6160.c
gnokii/common/phones/nk6510.c
gnokii/common/phones/nk7110.c

So I think by default the driver should be AT and only mobiles requiring a
special driver should be trying something else.

(In reply to comment #3)
<snip>
> So I think by default the driver should be AT and only mobiles requiring a
> special driver should be trying something else.

That's already what it does, and we actually connect twice to phones. The first
time to check the model of the phone, using the AT driver, then using the proper
driver. In your case, it should be the 6510 driver (or using the alias "6021").

I think your testing was badly made, modifying the phones.xml file will only
make it not connect a second time, it will still connect using the AT driver.

Please retest this using gnome-phone-manager 0.40 as available in F8 and rawhide.

I now retested both 0.30 and 0.40.

Unmodified 0.30 won't connect. Modified 0.30 with driver AT connects. These are
both as described above. What I now see is that gnokii indeed works with driver
being 6510. 6021 or 6510 in phones.xml does not work, only AT does. I don't know
why. The symptons are as above.

For 0.40 things are different. Not matter what driver is specified in phones.xml
0.40 always says:

root@localhost:~# gnome-phone-manager --identify /dev/ircomm0
Couldn't open PHONET device: Inappropriate ioctl for device

** (gnome-phone-manager:3115): WARNING **: gn_gsm_initialise: Command failed

** (gnome-phone-manager:3115): WARNING **: Couldn't connect to the
'/dev/ircomm0' phone: No reason
root@localhost:~# 

This on Fedora 8 with all latest updates, otherwise the system is all the same
for 0.30/0.40, only the gnome-phone-manager RPM is updated. Should I file
another bug about this?

Do you get the same error message using the following config file, running
"gnokii --identify"?

[global]
port = /dev/ircomm0
model = AT
initlength = default
connection = serial

Notice the different connection.

Also note that changing the driver in the phones.xml for your phone will make
absolutely no difference for gnome-phone-manager, as the first connection is
_always_ made using the AT driver.

With the config above I see no errors:

root@localhost:~# file .gnokiirc
.gnokiirc: ERROR: cannot open `.gnokiirc' (No such file or directory)
root@localhost:~# cat /etc/gnokiirc
[global]
port = /dev/ircomm0
model = AT
initlength = default
connection = serial
root@localhost:~# gnokii --identify
GNOKII Version 0.6.18
IMEI         : xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Manufacturer : Nokia
Model        : Nokia 6021
Product name : Nokia 6021
Revision     : V 04.50
root@localhost:~# 

Any news with this one? I'd be happy to provide more information if needed to
solve this issue. Thanks.

Hi, any news on this one? I tried latest RPM from rawhide but got the same
results said in Comment #5. Thanks.

Actually, I have some more information: g-p-m does not communicate with my Nokia
6021 even over a Nokia CA-42 cable:

root@localhost:~# gnome-phone-manager --identify /dev/ttyACM0
Couldn't open PHONET device: Inappropriate ioctl for device

** (gnome-phone-manager:2690): WARNING **: gn_gsm_initialise: Command failed

** (gnome-phone-manager:2690): WARNING **: Couldn't connect to the
'/dev/ttyACM0' phone: No reason
root@localhost:~# 

But again gnokii works all ok. (And wvdial, too).

I'm having same kind of troubles with NetworkManager at Bug 296851, could this
be some issue in a component common to g-p-m and NM, such as glib? (just guessing)

Cheers.

Well, the author of NetworkManager thinks that the problem is not in a shared
component so I think we're talking about a genuine g-p-m bug here :)

http://mail.gnome.org/archives/networkmanager-list/2008-March/msg00123.html

Still the same issue with 0.50 from rawhide.

Please test gnome-phone-manager-0.50-3.fc9.

I didn't find gnome-phone-manager-0.50-3.fc9 from rawhide (even from redhat.com)
so I built from source and it worked! Thanks!

Wicked. Let's close this then.

The build is here, if you want to use official RPMs instead.
http://koji.fedoraproject.org/koji/buildinfo?buildID=42910

Thanks for the link, I can confirm that the connection works also with the RPM.