Hide Forgot
+++ This bug was initially created as a clone of Bug #1021726 +++ Description of problem: Mongodb runs a test to see if it should preallocate its journal files and then preallocates them. This adds over 30 seconds to install time. Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): How reproducible: Mostly. You can get lucky and have it be faster on EC2. Steps to Reproduce: 1. Create an app 2. time rhc cartridge-add mongodb-2.2 Actual results: time > 30 seconds Expected results: time <= 30 seconds Additional info: Mon Oct 21 18:04:22.440 [initandlisten] preallocateIsFaster check took 4.107 secs Mon Oct 21 18:04:22.440 [initandlisten] preallocating a journal file /var/lib/openshift/5265a4c9ea8f50e54d000145/mongodb/data/journal/prealloc.0 Mon Oct 21 18:04:31.622 [initandlisten] preallocating a journal file /var/lib/openshift/5265a4c9ea8f50e54d000145/mongodb/data/journal/prealloc.1 Mon Oct 21 18:04:41.171 [initandlisten] preallocating a journal file /var/lib/openshift/5265a4c9ea8f50e54d000145/mongodb/data/journal/prealloc.2 Mon Oct 21 18:04:50.576 [FileAllocator] allocating new datafile /var/lib/openshift/5265a4c9ea8f50e54d000145/mongodb/data/local.ns, filling with zeroes... Unpacking the journal from a tar file (eg: from the install hook) seems to take less than 5 seconds on my devenv. --- Additional comment from Rob Millner on 2013-10-22 22:39:54 EDT --- Pre-creating the journal causes the cartridge install time to drop from around 60 seconds to around 15. --- Additional comment from Rob Millner on 2013-10-22 23:08:24 EDT --- Hmmm, I'm having trouble validating the original numbers. Creation seems fast now even without the journal pre-packaged. 20 seconds instead of almost 60. Without the pre-packaged journal: Tue Oct 22 23:00:49.941 [initandlisten] preallocateIsFaster=true 3.16 Tue Oct 22 23:00:49.942 [initandlisten] preallocating a journal file /var/lib/openshift/52673b43ea8f50855a000001/mongodb/data/journal/prealloc.0 Tue Oct 22 23:00:54.127 [initandlisten] preallocating a journal file /var/lib/openshift/52673b43ea8f50855a000001/mongodb/data/journal/prealloc.1 Tue Oct 22 23:00:58.573 [initandlisten] preallocating a journal file /var/lib/openshift/52673b43ea8f50855a000001/mongodb/data/journal/prealloc.2 Tue Oct 22 23:01:03.197 [FileAllocator] allocating new datafile /var/lib/openshift/52673b43ea8f50855a000001/mongodb/data/local.ns, filling with zeroes... I suspect that the write pattern for creating the journal files (ex: lots of fsync calls) has high delays when EC2 is having a bad day with storage and today happens to be a good day. So, on a good day it only saves 5 seconds and on a bad day it saves 25. --- Additional comment from Rob Millner on 2013-10-23 13:10:14 EDT --- Pull request: https://github.com/openshift/origin-server/pull/3968 --- Additional comment from openshift-github-bot on 2013-10-23 14:14:34 EDT --- Commit pushed to master at https://github.com/openshift/origin-server https://github.com/openshift/origin-server/commit/bd0dd1f6046ec2f6b33577e3ed0e3861b17635f4 Bug 1021726 - Create the mongo journal ahead of time and copy it into the gear for speed. --- Additional comment from Meng Bo on 2013-10-24 05:23:35 EDT --- Checked on devenv_3939, the expend time for adding mongodb is reduced to about 25s. # time rhc cartridge-add mongodb-2.2 -a php1 -l bmeng@redhat.com -pxx -k real 0m25.087s user 0m0.795s sys 0m0.424s From the mongo log, the journal file are allocated faster. Thu Oct 24 05:20:11.508 [initandlisten] preallocateIsFaster=true 5.56 Thu Oct 24 05:20:11.509 [initandlisten] preallocating a journal file /var/lib/openshift/5268e5fab07b10741700002e/mongodb/data/journal/prealloc.0 Thu Oct 24 05:20:16.793 [initandlisten] preallocating a journal file /var/lib/openshift/5268e5fab07b10741700002e/mongodb/data/journal/prealloc.1 Thu Oct 24 05:20:22.542 [initandlisten] preallocating a journal file /var/lib/openshift/5268e5fab07b10741700002e/mongodb/data/journal/prealloc.2 Thu Oct 24 05:20:27.940 [FileAllocator] allocating new datafile /var/lib/openshift/5268e5fab07b10741700002e/mongodb/data/local.ns, filling with zeroes... --- Additional comment from Rob Millner on 2013-10-24 13:28:14 EDT --- If you are seeing those log entries then my solution isn't working. Investigating. --- Additional comment from Rob Millner on 2013-10-24 14:07:47 EDT --- Ok, it works on my devenv: $ time rhc cartridge-add mongodb-2.2 -a rmtest ... real 0m15.484s user 0m0.646s sys 0m0.049s The following returns no output. $ rhc ssh rmtest cat mongodb/log/mongodb.log |grep 'preallocating a journal file' I'll see what's happening with devenv_3939. --- Additional comment from Rob Millner on 2013-10-24 14:43:26 EDT --- It works on devenv_3941: $ time rhc cartridge-add mongodb-2.2 -a rmtest Adding mongodb-2.2 to application 'rmtest' ... done ... real 0m10.483s user 0m0.669s sys 0m0.047s # No output from the following command. $ rhc ssh rmtest cat mongodb/log/mongodb.log |grep 'preallocating a journal file' Putting this back on Q/A to re-validate. Thanks! --- Additional comment from Meng Bo on 2013-10-24 22:44:47 EDT --- Checked on devenv_3942, # time rhc cartridge-add mongodb-2 -a perl1 -lbmeng@redhat.com -pxx -k Using mongodb-2.2 (MongoDB 2.2) for 'mongodb-2' ... real 0m25.482s user 0m0.758s sys 0m0.428s [root@ip-10-73-152-118 mongodb]# cat log/mongodb.log |grep prealloc Thu Oct 24 22:39:32.842 [initandlisten] options: { auth: true, bind_ip: "127.1.244.130", command: [ "run" ], config: "/var/lib/openshift/5269d951804377ea02000030/mongodb//conf/mongodb.conf", dbpath: "/var/lib/openshift/5269d951804377ea02000030/mongodb/data/", fork: "true", logpath: "/var/lib/openshift/5269d951804377ea02000030/mongodb/log/mongodb.log", nohttpinterface: "true", noprealloc: "true", pidfilepath: "/var/lib/openshift/5269d951804377ea02000030/mongodb/pid/mongodb.pid", quiet: "true", smallfiles: "true" } [root@ip-10-73-152-118 mongodb]# cat log/mongodb.log |grep preallocating [root@ip-10-73-152-118 mongodb]# Move bug to verified. --- Additional comment from John Skeoch on 2013-11-17 19:50:31 EST --- User rmillner@redhat.com's account has been closed --- Additional comment from John Skeoch on 2013-11-17 19:53:57 EST --- User rmillner@redhat.com's account has been closed
Add info:The bug exists on ose 2.1.z/2014-08-06.1.
I thought maybe the pre-create script just didn't get updated for SCL version. But it did: https://github.com/openshift/enterprise-server/blob/enterprise-2.1/cartridges/openshift-origin-cartridge-mongodb/bin/mkjournal Nothing important fails if it's broken, you just don't get this optimization.
It looks like the fix for this defect was shipped in RHBA-2014:0600 "Red Hat OpenShift Enterprise 2.1.1 bug fix and enhancement update" and would also have been included in RHSA-2014:1796 "Moderate: Red Hat OpenShift Enterprise 2.2 Release Advisory". QE, can you verify that the defect does not exist in OpenShift Enterprise 2.2?
Checked on ose 2.2 puddle OpenShiftEnterpriseErrata/2.2/2015-09-18.2/. Steps to test: 1.# time rhc cartridge add mongodb-2.4 -a phptest Adding mongodb-2.4 to application 'phptest' ... done mongodb-2.4 (MongoDB 2.4) ------------------------- Gears: Located with php-5.4 Connection URL: mongodb://$OPENSHIFT_MONGODB_DB_HOST:$OPENSHIFT_MONGODB_DB_PORT/ Database Name: phptest Password: 5tSBGmZDejKR Username: admin MongoDB 2.4 database added. Please make note of these credentials: Root User: admin Root Password: 5tSBGmZDejKR Database Name: phptest Connection URL: mongodb://$OPENSHIFT_MONGODB_DB_HOST:$OPENSHIFT_MONGODB_DB_PORT/ real 1m9.335s user 0m0.652s sys 0m0.198s 2.# rhc ssh phptest cat app-root/logs/mongodb.log |grep prealloc Warning: the RSA host key for 'phptest-domzyp.ose22-auto.com.cn' differs from the key for the IP address '10.66.79.203' Offending key for IP in /root/.ssh/known_hosts:49 Matching host key in /root/.ssh/known_hosts:65 Are you sure you want to continue connecting (yes/no)? yes note: noprealloc may hurt performance in many applications Mon Sep 21 11:04:29.179 [initandlisten] options: { auth: true, bind_ip: "127.8.160.130", command: [ "run" ], config: "/var/lib/openshift/domzyp-phptest-1/mongodb//conf/mongodb.conf", dbpath: "/var/lib/openshift/domzyp-phptest-1/mongodb/data/", nohttpinterface: "true", noprealloc: "true", pidfilepath: "/var/lib/openshift/domzyp-phptest-1/mongodb/pid/mongodb.pid", quiet: "true", smallfiles: "true" } From the test results, when add mongodb to app, though noprealloc is applied in mongodb, the adding time is still more than 30 seconds.
OpenShift Enterprise v2 has officially reached EoL. This product is no longer supported and bugs will be closed. Please look into the replacement enterprise-grade container option, OpenShift Container Platform v3. https://www.openshift.com/container-platform/ More information can be found here: https://access.redhat.com/support/policy/updates/openshift/