Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 122819
Sendmail with SMTP Authinfo
Last modified: 2007-11-30 17:10:42 EST
Description of Enhancement:
When Sendmail run with SMARTHOST or MAILHUB, there are somehow a
requirement for them to auth to the smtp server they are connecting.
This few line of code should be in the In the sendmail.mc and
Makefiles so that they can be configure easily.
Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable):
Sorry this is not a patch, just 2 line of code
for /etc/mail/sendmail.mc Add
dnl FEATURE(`virtusertable',`hash -o /etc/mail/virtusertable.db')dnl
for /etc/mail/Makefile @ line 10
POSSIBLE += $(shell test -f authinfo && echo authinfo.db)
Add one more files /etc/mail/authinfo.README writting how the authinfo
should be written
AuthInfo:smtp.servername.or.ip "U:username" "P:password" "M:LOGIN"
For M:LOGIN is the auth method.
This looks like a "fix" that might be useful to 1 in 10 users, but
would require the other 9 to comment out these options. Rather counter
I would say WONTFIX.
Hm. Maybe my conclusion was too hasty. I oversaw this FEATURE is
actually commented out. Still I am not sure if adding this is a big
Time for a Vote?
I think there might be a need for some Vote to happen for which bug to
be addin :)
But no hard for add them, As Adsl line is getting cheaper and not
everyong is getting an static ip, mail sending will have to pass
through the isp mail server somehow. So it is an advance to addin.
Why the extra authinfo directive in sendmail.mc and an extra file? The
AuthInfo data can go to the access file as well. Users should only
care that then /etc/mail/access* should have chmod 640.
This authinfo IS NOT for USERS but for the Sendmail server which will
be connecting to a MAIL_HUB OR SMART_HOST (In other words, SMTP Server
on the ISP/Co-Office) .
But they will be a requirement to auth before sending mail.
And this is why this Exists.
leonard: Any Good news about this?
Chan: It's not my bug. But if you want to know, I don't feel very
strongly either way. Adding it wouldn't hurt, but not adding it
wouldn't either. When you are setting up a mail server you should be
studying the docs anyway, so having one more config option predefined
in sendmail.mc shouldn't make a big difference.
This is not a standard configuration and btw. is easy to set up.
Closing as 'not a bug'.
You're right, Thomas... it's not a bug. However, I think it's a valid
RFE. More and more people are having need of AUTHINFO as ISP's start
to require SMTP AUTH (which is in itself a good thing).
So perhaps the way to solve it is just to add two or three lines of
text to /etc/mail/access showing how to set it up quickly? Likely it
will help more and more users over time.