Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 134110
xorg keyboard repeat rate has mind of its own
Last modified: 2007-11-30 17:10:50 EST
From Bugzilla Helper: User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; U; Linux i686; en-US; rv:1.7.3) Gecko/20040922 Description of problem: I recently did an up2date upgrade on xorg, and xorg.conf changed the following keyboard config line during the upgrade: Driver "kbd" It used to be: Driver "keyboard" With the new driver ("kbd"), all seemed fine until I held a key down for a couple seconds. The rate would start off fast, but then slow down. I tried changing this with the following command: xset r rate 250 30 But this did not help. When I changed the xorg.conf setting back to Driver "keyboard", the repeat rate worked as expected again. Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): xorg-x11-6.7.0-9 How reproducible: Always Steps to Reproduce: 1. Start Xorg with Driver "kbd" in the keyboard configuration. Actual Results: Keyboard repeat rate would start out fast, then slow down by itself. Expected Results: The keyboard rate should have stayed at a constant rate. Additional info: Here is the entire keyboard configuration section from xorg.conf, in the config that causes the problem: Section "InputDevice" Identifier "Keyboard0" Driver "kbd" Option "XkbModel" "pc105" Option "XkbLayout" "us" EndSection
Similar problem here. I upgraded FC1 -> FC2 with anaconda. After that the keyboard repeat worked, but it was not adjustable. The Preferences -> Keyboard gnome GUI had no effect at all. Everything had worked fine for me in FC1. I changed Driver "kbd" to Driver "keyboard" in xorg.conf as the original poster suggests and now everything works 100% fine again. Not sure what I'll lose/break by doing that however -- there must be a reason why they switched to kbd :-) xorg-x11-6.7.0-9 kernel-2.6.8-1.521
Now I just upgraded again, this time FC2->FC3 with anaconda and now I'm experiencing the exact same problem as the original poster and am no longer having the problem I recently reported in FC2! Anaconda changed my xorg.conf line back to kbd and now the rate is correct and the adjustments work, but I too get that weird slow-down effect. This may only affect people who, like me, set their repeat rate very fast. I'd say after half a second the rate goes down by about 40%. It's a bit hard to perceive at first. I just thought it was interesting how the symptoms differed between FC2 and FC3 yet the xorg versions were the same (originally). My xorg is now xorg-x11-6.8.1-12.
I'm seeing this to on FC3. I also experienced this behavior on FC2.
This is getting to be a major problem and it makes no sense. I've been using FC3 a week with Driver "kbd" and here's what happened: 1. Starts out ok, keyboard repeat rate is quite fast, as I have it set in Gnome preferences. 2. After a while (hours) the rate will start to go down. It's weird but it still is fast for the first half second you hold it down and then it gets slow. 3. After days it just goes nothing but slow. Not even a fast first half second! 4. Changing the gnome keyboard preferences setting has no affect at this point. I'm going to reboot with driver "keyboard" today and report back on how that behaves. Note: I am using a high-end IBM "clicky" PS2 keyboard. It works fine in all other respects, and fine on my Windows box. Note: I am using a KVM switch: DLInk DKVM-4. None of these problems ever occurred before I upgraded to FC3 (and Xorg).
This is *really* getting *weird*. I'm still using Driver "kbd" as I forgot to switch before starting X. I've been using it all day (10 hours) and for the entire day the repeat rate has been slow (30 cps?) and unadjustable... EXCEPT for about 3 or 4 times where the repeat rate was back up to my desired rate (50-60 cps? just a guess) for about 1 second for no apparent reason. Each time I tried to immediately figure out what I did to trigger it but I could find no common cause. Each time it happened I was just typing as normal or clicking the focus on some windows.
Another week another weird report. I've been using Driver "keyboard" this time. For the longest time (days) it seemed ok though the speed would vary occasionally between 100% to maybe 80% of my desired rate. Today however, for no apparent reason, the repeat rate is definitely doing the 100% for 1 second of holding a key then down to 10% (like 5cps) of my desired rate after that 1 second. I've never seen it this slow. It's the same behaviour I've been reporting above, but much slower. I'm waiting to see if it goes away or fixes itself (without quitting X) and will report back.
Anyone else who has this bug please report whether or not you use a KVM and if so, what kind (brand, interface type).
I have this problem on two different computers, neither with a KVM switch.
This problem should be fixed in 6.8.2 which will come out early January. We have RPMs of the first release candidate in rawhide now, please try it out and see if it fixes this problem. Thanks.
Thanks for the tip, I will try and get those and report back. In the meantime, I've just opened an xorg bugzilla entry for this as my searching showed no listed bugs on repeat rates: https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=2122
I was about to install the devel test releases when the bug hit me again and I was able to note the precise effects in much more detail this time as it was really strange. After using X for roughly 5 hours all of a sudden, while I was typing but taking a quick break to think, the system acted like I was holding down the spacebar and put about 30 spaces into my window at high speed. I must have freaked and hit a key and it stopped it. I definitely had not typed a space within a few seconds of that happening. AND I noticed for sure this time that right as this happened the num lock key LED turned off! And even though the numlock light is off, the system still thinks numlock is on (the keys still produce numbers)!! Now I just tapped num lock and the light stayed off (ie: no toggle). I tapped it again and it went on. And now my keyboard repeat rate is down to the stock 30cps (it feels like). I'm using driver "kbd" this time.
Trevor, there is an upstream bugzilla entry for this, it's just closed: https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1651 I marked your new bug as a duplicate of that one. Did the upgrade help?
I'm using a KVM. It is a Starview, 2 port keyboard/mouse/video KVM, from StarTech.com. SV211K is the number on it.
Yes, the upgrade appears to have fixed it (so far!). It's been 2+ days and it hasn't acted weird yet. (Using *-6.8.1.901) Thanks!
Nearly a week now and it's 100% perfect. The problem is well and truly fixed (for me at least!) in the .901 version. Thanks all! Out all the bugs I've come across this one was the absolute worst to live with!
Hmm, seems like I forgot to close this bug.