(In reply to Honggang LI from comment #0)
c#18 is very long, and requires the reader to parse, and all readers to parse to same conclusion.

A clean summary/description of the problem should be stated here.

also, you mention 7.4 opensm version, then mellanox, then upstream commit-id.
What point are you trying to make?
What is the reader suppose to conclude from the different versions -- b/c these versions almost always differ at any point in time.

(In reply to Don Dutile from comment #2)
> (In reply to Honggang LI from comment #0)
> c#18 is very long, and requires the reader to parse, and all readers to
> parse to same conclusion.
> 
> A clean summary/description of the problem should be stated here.


Summary:

To setup the MTU for MC group, the 'mtu=xxx' must to be the first field of mgroup_flag. Otherwise, opensm will ignore it and set the MTU to default value 2048.

Good configuration. MTU will be set to 4096. 'mut=5' is the first field of mgroup_flag.
[root@rdma03 opensm]# cat partitions.conf.default 
Default=0x7fff,ipoib, mtu=5 rate=12:ALL=full;
                      ^^^^^

Bad configuration. MTU will be set to 2048. 'mut=5' is the second field of mgroup flag.
[root@rdma03 opensm]# cat partitions.conf.default 
Default=0x7fff,ipoib, rate=12 mtu=5:ALL=full;
                      ^^^^^^^

> also, you mention 7.4 opensm version, then mellanox, then upstream commit-id.
> What point are you trying to make?

Issue can be reproduced with all of those versions of opensm.

(In reply to Honggang LI from comment #3)
Thanks for all that clarification!

Now I understand your remark about the first field... I didn't get that before.

So, is upstream fixed yet, or do you have to post a patch for it?

https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1534869#c21

Copy and paste the explanation in here.


> [root@rdma-master ~]$ cat /etc/rdma/partitions-ib0.conf  | grep mtu
> # mtu = 
> Default=0x7fff, rate=6 mtu=5 scope=2, defmember=full:
> Default=0x7fff, ipoib, rate=6 mtu=5 scope=2:
                         ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Because of two issues, we failed to set the MTU to 4K.
1) The configuration file is wrong. There MUST BE a comma (,) between the mgroup_flag flags.

Default=0x7fff, ipoib, rate=6 mtu=5 scope=2:

should be:

Default=0x7fff, ipoib, rate=6, mtu=5, scope=2:
                             ^      ^


I believe we had been mislead by the example configuration file "/etc/rdma/partitions.conf" and upstream doc source file "opensm-top-dir/doc/partition-config.txt". No doc emphasize that the field of mgroup_flag must be spilt with a "comma".

We should update these two files.

2) The function "parse_name_token" is error prone. It gives us a wrong 'flval' when wrong configuration passed into it. In fact, it should raise an error.


I instrumented upstream opensm source code. Output with wrong configuration file.
----------------------------
osm_prtn_config_parse_file open /etc/opensm/partitions.conf
osm_prtn_config_parse_file read line (1) (# Bad configuration, ib0's mtu will be 2044
)
osm_prtn_config_parse_file read line (2) (# Default=0x7fff,ipoib, rate=12 mtu=5:ALL=full;
)
osm_prtn_config_parse_file read line (3) (
)
osm_prtn_config_parse_file read line (4) (# Good configuration, ib0's mtu will be 4092
)
osm_prtn_config_parse_file read line (5) (Default=0x7fff,ipoib, mtu=5 rate=12:ALL=full;
)

===>  parse_name_token return ret=(15) name=(Default), id=(0x7fff)

===>  parse_name_token return ret=(6) flag=(ipoib), flval=((null))

===>  parse_name_token return ret=(15) flag=(mtu), flval=(5 rate=12) <=====
                                                   ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

IT SHOULD RAISE AN ERROR IN HERE, AS WRONG 'FLVAL' RETURNED. THAT IS WHY OPENSM ONLY HONOR THE FIRST FIELD OF MG_GROUP_FLAG.

===>  parse_name_token return ret=(9) name=(ALL), flag=(full)
----------------------------


> ib0_2=0x0002, rate=7 mtu=5 scope=2, defmember=full:
> ib0_2=0x0002, ipoib, rate=7 mtu=5 scope=2:
> ib0_4=0x0004, rate=3 mtu=5 scope=2, defmember=full:
> ib0_4=0x0004, ipoib, rate=3 mtu=5 scope=2:
> ib0_6=0x0006, rate=12 mtu=5 scope=2, defmember=full:
> ib0_6=0x0006, ipoib, rate=12 mtu=5 scope=2:
> 
> 
> mtu=5 means MTU==4K.

024fe73e4481 opensm.8.in:  Emphasize that the fields of mgroup_flag must be split with "comma"
1f82c22a1237 partition-config.txt: Emphasize that the fields of mgroup_flag must be split with "comma"
04d2a8be0305 osm_prtn_config.c: parse_group_flag log suspicious group flag value

Upstream patches fix this issue.

Since the problem described in this bug report should be
resolved in a recent advisory, it has been closed with a
resolution of ERRATA.

For information on the advisory, and where to find the updated
files, follow the link below.

If the solution does not work for you, open a new bug report.

https://access.redhat.com/errata/RHBA-2019:2100