Spec Name or Url: http://fedora.lowlatency.de/review/wmapmload.spec SRPM Name or Url: http://fedora.lowlatency.de/review/wmapmload-0.3.4-1.src.rpm Description: Wmapmload monitors your apm status in an lcd display fashion
Would you consider to rename the package to x11-applet-wmapmload? This kind of packages are really small, they are very usefull to small/older systems that do not support the heavier desktop environments (kde/gnome/xfce). In this case they are sufficiently small to be reasonable to have a single package containing them all. I know that this has lots of drawbacks and so I propose to give them a commom prefix. I suggest x11-applet but any other name that conveys the same meaning is OK with me. I have approved a previous package wmacpi from you and I propose to rename it as well. Comments?
I am not sure on how to deal with this. For me there is the conflict of original name vs. prefix-name. I don't know which one is better. Maybe we can satisfy both and make a virtual package which requires all dockapps that are part of FE. This way we can still use the original names of the packages and also have a nice and easy way to keep track of all the dockapps. As to the naming of such a package? Maybe x11-dockapps? x11-applets? And if we take this approach we might want to have some discussions about that as we would need some sort of common process for this.
I will present these doubts in fedora packaging list and I will wait for some output before returning here. FWIW, the package looks OK. Nice work.
+ the package builds in mock/x86_64 + rpmlint W: wmapmload no-version-in-last-changelog W: wmapmload-debuginfo no-version-in-last-changelog These can be ignored. + package name follows the guideline + package follows packaging guidelines + license is valid, matches upstream and is included + spec file is legible and is written in American English + source matches upstream + Requires and BR OK + files ownership OK Approved. One suggestion, replace the package version in Source by %{version}. It will save you some typing for future versions. :-)