Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 18668
users may control contents of catman pages
Last modified: 2007-04-18 12:29:06 EDT
1) GROFF_TMAC_PATH is a colon-separated list of directories to search for
the macro files in, and man does nothing to stop this getting passed to
groff. By creating their own macros, groff can be made to write arbitrary
data to the catman page.
2) GZIP environment variable can contain options to gzip, which is used to
compress the catpages. This can be used to write garbage to the catpage or
to cause other strange results.
3) The directory it uses to place catfiles follows symlinks. For example:
+ cat1 -> /var/catman/cat1
man -M . -c 1 ls
Will read the ls.1 manpage from ./man1/ls.1 and write it to
4) Race conditions on the cat file. I'm not going to give examples of
where this occurs because it occurs just about everywhere.
This is impossible to fix.Since the file is generated as user, it is always
writeable by that user.
The only possibility to fix this would be making man setuid root, which would
enable much much bigger security issues.
If you want to be sure nobody plays with the catman pages, use man -c or disable
catman pages in /etc/man.conf.