Description of problem: With the new EFK stack for OCP 4.5 the indices are not created as was the case with previous versions of OCP prior to 4.5 Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): Default efk stack for ocp 4.5 and higher How reproducible: New install of OCP 4.5 cluster logging Upgrade to OCP 4.5 cluster logging Steps to Reproduce: 1. 2. 3. Actual results: No indices available Expected results: Having Indices created as was the case with prior versions Additional info: This is, rightly, perceived as a huge hassle to the customer. Having over 50 clusters with hundreds of users Creating new development and testing clusters - it becomes a real hog Having each developer spend time doing it let alone the cost of educating the users Overall lots of hassle and noise
Setting target release to the active development branch (4.7.0) for consideration/evaluation/triage. Where requested, appropriate and fixes available, clones will be created for prior releases once a resolution is determined.
(In reply to Ilan Green from comment #0) > Additional info: > This is, rightly, perceived as a huge hassle to the customer. > Having over 50 clusters with hundreds of users > Creating new development and testing clusters - it becomes a real hog > Having each developer spend time doing it let alone the cost of educating > the users Regular user's will need to create one index-pattern the first time they log into Kibana. Admin user's will need to create three. The steps are well documented in the logging section of the OpenShift documentation and literally amounts to a sum total of three steps. Please work with PM to open an RFE if you feel this requires further attention as the functionality is as intended per discussions during release planning. Closing NOTABUG [1] https://docs.openshift.com/container-platform/4.5/logging/viewing/cluster-logging-visualizer.html#cluster-logging-visualizer-indices_cluster-logging-visualizer
(In reply to Jeff Cantrill from comment #3) > (In reply to Ilan Green from comment #0) > > > Additional info: > > This is, rightly, perceived as a huge hassle to the customer. > > Having over 50 clusters with hundreds of users > > Creating new development and testing clusters - it becomes a real hog > > Having each developer spend time doing it let alone the cost of educating > > the users > > Regular user's will need to create one index-pattern the first time they log > into Kibana. Admin user's will need to create three. The steps are well > documented in the logging section of the OpenShift documentation and > literally amounts to a sum total of three steps. > > Please work with PM to open an RFE if you feel this requires further > attention as the functionality is as intended per discussions during release > planning. Closing NOTABUG > > [1] > https://docs.openshift.com/container-platform/4.5/logging/viewing/cluster- > logging-visualizer.html#cluster-logging-visualizer-indices_cluster-logging- > visualizer Would it be possible please to share the rationale for this change compared with previous versions (i.e. the "discussions during release planning")? As noted in the description this will soon become a real hassle for large customers with large development environments where cluster creation is frequent Thanks