Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 248366
chgrp permission denied for file owner
Last modified: 2007-11-30 17:12:10 EST
I have a situation where an automated process running as apache needs to share a
file with another user, foo. For security reasons, it would be preferable if
this file were not readable to other Unix users. The obvious solution is to
have apache "chgrp foo FILENAME", but chgrp complains that permission to do this
is denied, even though the file is owned by apache and has the group set to
apache. This does not make much sense to me. It also seems to have security
implications, because now apache must make the file world-readable in order to
This is a kernel permission check. Changing component and reassigning.
apache cannot change a file's group unless apache is a member of the new group.
Any particular reason for that? As the file owner, apache can get
read/write/execute access at any time, so it seems that the only thing that
restriction does is prevent sharing access with groups of which it is not a
member. I'm not sure why that would be desirable.
1) user creates script
2) user makes script setgid
3) user changes the group on script to one w/elevated privs that they aren't a
4) user runs setgid script with elevated privs they shouldn't have
I'd suggest perhaps making your user foo a member of the apache group if it
needs r/w access to that file.
Ah, that makes sense. Thanks for the explanation.