Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 249634
init wakes up every 5 seconds
Last modified: 2014-03-16 23:07:44 EDT
As of sysvinit-2.86-17, init wakes up every 5 seconds. It looks like most of it's time is spent in select() in
check_init_fifo(), which has a 5-second timeout. That appears to accomplish two things:
1. lets it poll regularly to see if INIT_FIFO ("/dev/initctl") has changed. This could be replaced with inotify,
if it's necessary at all.
2. lets it poll for signals. (If it is in select() when they arrive, it will get an EINTR, but one could arrive
between it checking and entering select().) This could be replaced with the "self-pipe trick".
Somewhat glib, but if we're getting to the point where an every five second
wakeup is an issue, we're doing a lot better than I thought we were.
More concretely - does inotify actually work correctly on pipes?
There are worse ones, but they look harder to fix. :( In particular, I'm mulling over the python-gobject
one; there seem to be a bunch of them inside the kernel; and the !@#$@! proprietary VMware tools wake
up way too often.
But to answer your real question: I don't believe inotify works any differently on named pipes than on any
other type of inode. I've never actually used the interface before, but since you asked, I just tried whipping
up a test program, and it seems to be doing the right thing. If that path is created/deleted/moved, it says
so. That's what init seems to be expecting, though I'm not sure why you'd actually do that.
'Fixed' with upstart now in rawhide. Setting to wontfix for sysvinit.