Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 249956
RFE: make empty debuginfo package a build error
Last modified: 2008-04-03 03:29:38 EDT
I can't think of a case where producing an empty debuginfo package would be
useful, but empty debuginfo packages are often signs of something wrong with the
build, see eg. http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Packaging/Debuginfo
So, how about making it an error in rpm-build/redhat-rpm-config? For example
something like this appended to find-debuginfo.sh would do the trick:
if [ ! -s $LISTFILE ] ; then
echo ERROR: empty debuginfo package created
The error message could be improved, but exactly how depends somewhat on
whether/if this is going to be done in redhat-rpm-config or rpm-build.
BTW, just adding that to find-debuginfo.sh as is and doing nothing else isn't
the right thing to do - it'll break noarch package builds. Anyway, this idea
is/was being discussed on the fedora-packaging list too, and has received some
positive feedback thus far.
I dislike it, but I'll act according to what is decided. I very much dislike
aborting builds just because of some arbitrary logic like this - there might be
a reason one would have an empty debuginfo package, and now we're making it
impossible to build those packages.
There could be a way to allow them, it doesn't have to be made impossible. The
way I see it, this RFE is analoguous to having builds fail if there are
unpackaged files. That can be overridden by setting a variable too.
Anyway, there's no decision yet whether this is found desirable, it has been
requested that FESCO discusses it in a near future meeting.