Bug 429525

Created attachment 292354 [details]
cluster.conf example

Actually, you're looking in the wrong place (and it's my fault for telling you
to look there).  I'm sorry for pointing you in the wrong direction - the errors
aren't actually from cluster.conf - they're from a dirty /usr/share/cluster.

Clean up /usr/share/cluster ...

# cd /usr/share/cluster
# rm -f *~ *.rpm*

rg_test works on that conf file (note that both VMs are displayed below).  I
left some errors (showing duplicate resource agents):

[root@ayanami daemons]# ./rg_test ../resources test ~lhh/futon.conf
Using ../resources as resource agent path
Running in test mode.

Warning: Ignoring ../resources/ip.sh.rpmsave: Bad extension .rpmsave
Error storing fs: Duplicate
Error storing clusterfs: Duplicate
Error storing fs: Duplicate
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ duplicate resource agent errors

Loaded 21 resource rules
=== Resources List ===
Resource type: vm [INLINE]
Instances: 1/1
Agent: vm.sh
Attributes:
  name = vm-xennfs1-pru [ primary ]
  domain = xen_pru [ reconfig ]
  autostart = 0 [ reconfig ]
  hardrecovery = 0 [ reconfig ]
  exclusive = 0 [ reconfig ]
  recovery = disable [ reconfig ]
  path = /guests/virtdata/scripts:/etc/xen
  migrate = live
  depend_mode = hard
  max_restarts = 0 [ reconfig ]
  restart_expire_time = 0 [ reconfig ]

Resource type: vm [INLINE]
Instances: 1/1
Agent: vm.sh
Attributes:
  name = vm-xennfs2-pru [ primary ]
  domain = xen_pru [ reconfig ]
  autostart = 0 [ reconfig ]
  hardrecovery = 0 [ reconfig ]
  exclusive = 0 [ reconfig ]
  recovery = disable [ reconfig ]
  path = /guests/virtdata/scripts:/etc/xen
  migrate = live
  depend_mode = hard
  max_restarts = 0 [ reconfig ]
  restart_expire_time = 0 [ reconfig ]

=== Resource Tree ===
vm {
  name = "vm-xennfs1-pru";
  domain = "xen_pru";
  autostart = "0";
  hardrecovery = "0";
  exclusive = "0";
  recovery = "disable";
  path = "/guests/virtdata/scripts:/etc/xen";
  migrate = "live";
  depend_mode = "hard";
  max_restarts = "0";
  restart_expire_time = "0";
}
vm {
  name = "vm-xennfs2-pru";
  domain = "xen_pru";
  autostart = "0";
  hardrecovery = "0";
  exclusive = "0";
  recovery = "disable";
  path = "/guests/virtdata/scripts:/etc/xen";
  migrate = "live";
  depend_mode = "hard";
  max_restarts = "0";
  restart_expire_time = "0";
}
=== Failover Domains ===
Failover domain: xen_pru
Flags: Ordered Restricted 
  Node node1 (id 1, priority 1)
  Node node2 (id 2, priority 2)
=== Event Triggers ===
Event Priority Level 100:
  Name: Default
    (Any event)
    File: /usr/share/cluster/default_event_script.sl

If it was a question of unique/non-unique, the error would look like this:

Error: Primary attribute collision. type=vm attr=name value=vm-xennfs1-pru
Error storing vm resource

You, however, are correct - rgmanager does not allow configuration of the same
VM name even if restricted failover domains do not overlap.  For example, the
following configuration would result in the above error collision error:

        <rm log_facility="local4" log_level="5">
                <resources/>
                <failoverdomains>
                        <failoverdomain name="domain1" ordered="1" restricted="1">
                                <failoverdomainnode name="node1" priority="1"/>
                                <failoverdomainnode name="node2" priority="2"/>
                        </failoverdomain>
                        <failoverdomain name="domain2" ordered="1" restricted="1">
                                <failoverdomainnode name="node3" priority="1"/>
                                <failoverdomainnode name="node4" priority="2"/>
                        </failoverdomain>
                </failoverdomains>
                <vm autostart="0" domain="domain1" exclusive="0"
name="vm-xennfs1-pru" path="/guests/virtdata/scripts:/etc/xen" recovery="disable"/>
                <vm autostart="0" domain="domain2" exclusive="0"
name="vm-xennfs1-pru" path="/guests/virtdata/scripts:/etc/xen" recovery="disable"/>
        </rm>

This is a known limitation.  It is kind of a design flaw - basically, resource
placement policies and individual resource configuration are not the same thing
in rgmanager.  Fortunately, it's fairly easy to make rgmanager allow multiple
domains with the same name.

Created attachment 292381 [details]
Example of how to allow multiple instances of the same domain name

Untested.  The idea is that you can provide a non-unique name_override in
cluster.conf which is the -real- Xen domain name for the VM.