Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 49129
initscript thinks my gateway is DNS
Last modified: 2005-10-31 17:00:50 EST
From Bugzilla Helper:
User-Agent: Mozilla/4.77 [en] (X11; U; Linux 2.4.6-2 i686)
Description of problem:
I have a adsl with Cisco 677 adsl modem. It works a route and gateway
Steps to Reproduce:
1. start te pc
Actual Results: iniscripte make a resolv.conf with gateway as name server
and copies my rigth resolv to resolv.conf.sv. Dns does not work but I gan
acess internet with ip adresse
Expected Results: DNS should work
I have gone back to initscripte from redhat 7.1
Umm, initscripts 5.60 is older than what shipped with RHL71 (5.83)...
sorry initscript 6.02-1 had this error, I mistype it.
Did you specify PEERDNS, MS_DNS1 or MS_DNS2 anywhere in the configuration?
What data is your DHCP server telling you? Does it report proper nameservers? If not, resolv.conf
nameserver data may get replaced with dynamic data obtained from dhcp.
My adsl-server does not have proper dns is connect to my ISP by using POP over
ethernet. It also is a DCHP server to my pc but is does not have dns. This is
provided by my ISP.
The real question is whether your DHCP server gives the DNS addresses
(either automatically or manually), not whether they should be used or not.
You might want to check that out with 'pump -i eth0 -s'.
This is from pump -i eth0 -s, it has no dns.
Boot server 10.0.0.1
Next server 0.0.0.0
Renewal time: Mon Jul 23 10:53:30 2001
Expiration time: Mon Jul 23 10:55:45 2001
I upgraded to latest from rawhide, it hade the same problem. pump -i eth0 -d
could not display anything. I odd problemen why did resolve.conf.sv appear.
As a workaround, you could set the nameservers in DHCP server as you would set them statically (184.108.40.206, ...); this
way, DHCP run on the client should set them properly.
This doesn't cure the actual problem though..
You could also try running using dhcpcd and not pump.
A workaround for me copy resolv.conf.sv over resolv.conf. Then I can use dns and
access the internet. Though I can not configure my ISP nameserver, I don.t have
acces code. To solve this I have to edit my own machine. An workaround is to put
cp /etc/resolv.conf.sv /etc/resolv in startingscrip.
.save is what is saved by the init script yes. But this is not a real workaround, as resolv.conf will get changed at boot.
You do have access to your DHCP server, there is no need to access DNS itself; just add DNS servers to being
configured using DHCP.
I do have access to my adsl modem but I rather not start modify by using telnet.
How do I configurer eth0 to use dhcp instead of pump. As an workaround I have
gone back to redhat 7.1 initscript.
I read my /var/log/message and it was using pump. I removed pump but my problem
was there still. An solution is to make /etc/resolv.conf unwritablel even for
I was able to duplicat this problem with initscript from redhat 7.1 by removing
pump. Somehow redhat 7.1 initscript use pump first while rawhide initscript use
dhcpcd. This problem lies in dchpcd since it can not get proper DNS from my
ISP. Therfore I moving this bug to dhcpcd package.
An soultion to this problem would be to add an option to not let dchpcd
overwritte /etc/resolve.conf or use statical dns like my adsl-router.
Thos options already exist. See
/usr/share/docs/initscripts-<version>/sysconfig.txt, search for resolv.conf.
Assigning back to dhcpcd.
I put PEERDNS=no which solved my problem. I can now use pump -i eth0 -s , and I
get the same reulats as above. My adsl modem uses POP over ehernet while
servering as a DHCP/firewale witth statical DNS from my ISP provider.
Although the cause of the problem wasn't discovered, a satisfactory workaround
was, and it's quite likely that the problem was caused outside of pump (e.g.
inside the gateway or ISP is my guess), so I am closing this.