I recently purchased twenty systems from VA with RedHat Linux running on them. I was, quite frankly, shocked at how many commands were installed without manpages, and also how many manpages has completely bogus "SEE ALSO" sections. This should never happen, because the quality control people in release management should have caught these before they hit the customers. While no one is perfect, the magnitude of the problem on these Linux systems is enormous--far, far worse than I've ever seen before on any Unix system. Here are the commands that have no manpages. This is really nasty. When there's a command on the system, the sysadmin and his users need to be able to look up what it's for. (There's also a problem with libraries without manpages, but I haven't come up with a good way to automate this yet.) At the bottom of this listing I enclose the program I just whipped together to figure these out. As a long-time customer of VA and as a RedHat stockholder, I counsel, urg, beg, and implore you in the name of all that is sane and rational to make this part of your release check. My point of view is that it isn't fair to the user of your system for you to ever include something that isn't documented. When I have been part of releases, either the old Unix releases from years ago or even the new Perl releases today, the rule was simple: if it isn't documented, it isn't shipped. I think you should do the same. The KDE etc folks have been particularly remiss in this area. I am probably going to draw up a long and involved essay decrying the post-literate Unix society into which we are degenerating. Even if something is included in some "help" button and series of cascading menus, this is not searchable, printable, etc. This is not your fault, but it is a growing cancer that is going to leave us all as helpless as Windows users or MVS users of old. Let me give you an example. I was trying to set up twenty of your systems, all of which I purchased for cold hard cash. I've been fighting with the whole pam authentication crud. There was virtually no documentation on this, and what there was pointed me at SEE ALSOs that didn't even exist, such as pam(8). I am not happy to have to use Alta Vista to look up the documentation for a vendor's system. I wasn't even on the net at the time! So I was unable to chase this or that random URL. Sigh. I've just had a very hard weekend with RedHat. --tom PART 1: Program to find orphaned commands #!/usr/bin/perl # docless - find commands that don't have manpages @bindirs = qw{ /bin /usr/bin /sbin /usr/sbin /usr/games /usr/X11R6/bin }; for (@scratch = @bindirs) { push(@manpath,$_) if ! /^\.?$/ && s![^/+]*$!man! && -d && ! $seen{$_}++ && do { ($dev,$ino) = stat(_); ! $seen{$dev,$ino}++ }; } $manpath = join(":", @manpath), "\n"; print "manpath is $manpath\n"; $ENV{MANPATH} = $manpath; $| = 1; foreach $dir (@bindirs) { chdir($dir) || die "chdir $dir: $!"; foreach $file (grep { -f && -x _ } glob("*")) { next if $file =~ /-\d+(\.\d+)+$/; # skip versioned bins print "$dir/$file: ", `man -w '$file' 2>&1`; } } PART 2: List of orphaned commands /bin/ash.static /bin/csh /bin/remadmin /bin/rpm.shared /sbin/e2fsck.shared /sbin/fsck.ext2 /sbin/genpowerfail /sbin/ifdown /sbin/ifup /sbin/insmod.static /sbin/install-info /sbin/installkernel /sbin/ipmaddr /sbin/iptunnel /sbin/loglevel /sbin/minilogd /sbin/mkfs.ext2 /sbin/mount.ncp /sbin/mount.ncpfs /sbin/mount.smb /sbin/mount.smbfs /sbin/probe /sbin/pwdb_chkpwd /sbin/quotaoff /sbin/raidhotadd /sbin/raidhotremove /sbin/rmmod.static /sbin/rpcdebug /sbin/service /sbin/setsysfont /sbin/sln /usr/X11R6/bin/ASSound /usr/X11R6/bin/Magick-config /usr/X11R6/bin/RunWM /usr/X11R6/bin/RunWM.AfterStep /usr/X11R6/bin/RunWM.Fvwm95 /usr/X11R6/bin/RunWM.MWM /usr/X11R6/bin/RunWM.WindowMaker /usr/X11R6/bin/XConsole /usr/X11R6/bin/Xmark /usr/X11R6/bin/Xprt /usr/X11R6/bin/Xtest /usr/X11R6/bin/Xwrapper /usr/X11R6/bin/afterstepdoc /usr/X11R6/bin/ascommand.pl /usr/X11R6/bin/ascp /usr/X11R6/bin/asppp /usr/X11R6/bin/freetemp /usr/X11R6/bin/gccmakedep /usr/X11R6/bin/get-wraster-flags /usr/X11R6/bin/ghostview /usr/X11R6/bin/jazip /usr/X11R6/bin/mergelib /usr/X11R6/bin/nxterm /usr/X11R6/bin/scanpci /usr/X11R6/bin/sxpm /usr/X11R6/bin/wkdemenu.pl /usr/X11R6/bin/wm-oldmenu2new /usr/X11R6/bin/wmaker.inst /usr/X11R6/bin/wmclock /usr/X11R6/bin/wsetfont /usr/X11R6/bin/x11amp /usr/X11R6/bin/xb_check /usr/X11R6/bin/xbanner /usr/X11R6/bin/xbill /usr/X11R6/bin/xdoom /usr/X11R6/bin/xfishtank /usr/X11R6/bin/xfm.install /usr/X11R6/bin/xg3 /usr/X11R6/bin/xhextris /usr/X11R6/bin/xkbbell /usr/X11R6/bin/xkbvleds /usr/X11R6/bin/xkbwatch /usr/X11R6/bin/xmahjongg /usr/X11R6/bin/xmdb /usr/X11R6/bin/xplaymidi /usr/X11R6/bin/xrn /usr/X11R6/bin/xsysinfo /usr/bin/Esetroot /usr/bin/Etbg /usr/bin/Etcolors.sh /usr/bin/Etmenu.sh /usr/bin/GnomeScott /usr/bin/[ /usr/bin/aclocal /usr/bin/addr /usr/bin/addresses /usr/bin/addtosmbpass /usr/bin/aktion /usr/bin/alarmd /usr/bin/amaya /usr/bin/another_clock_applet /usr/bin/ark /usr/bin/as86 /usr/bin/asclock_applet /usr/bin/autoconf /usr/bin/autoheader /usr/bin/automake /usr/bin/autopasswd /usr/bin/autoreconf /usr/bin/autoscan /usr/bin/autoupdate /usr/bin/b2m /usr/bin/background-properties-capplet /usr/bin/bashbug /usr/bin/battery_applet /usr/bin/bdftops /usr/bin/bell-properties-capplet /usr/bin/bzip2recover /usr/bin/bzless /usr/bin/c++ /usr/bin/c2ph /usr/bin/catchsegv /usr/bin/cc /usr/bin/ccexample /usr/bin/cddaslave /usr/bin/cddbslave /usr/bin/cdplay /usr/bin/cdplayer_applet /usr/bin/charpick_applet /usr/bin/clockmail_applet /usr/bin/codepage /usr/bin/comanche /usr/bin/controlpanel_check /usr/bin/convert_smbpasswd /usr/bin/cpumemusage_applet /usr/bin/ctali /usr/bin/db_archive /usr/bin/db_checkpoint /usr/bin/db_deadlock /usr/bin/db_dump /usr/bin/db_dump185 /usr/bin/db_load /usr/bin/db_printlog /usr/bin/db_recover /usr/bin/db_stat /usr/bin/debugsh /usr/bin/devdump /usr/bin/dialer_applet /usr/bin/disable-paste /usr/bin/diskusage_applet /usr/bin/dns-helper /usr/bin/dox /usr/bin/drivemount_applet /usr/bin/dsirc /usr/bin/e-conf /usr/bin/ee /usr/bin/eesh /usr/bin/emacs-nox /usr/bin/emacsclient /usr/bin/enlightenment /usr/bin/epp /usr/bin/esd /usr/bin/esdcat /usr/bin/esdctl /usr/bin/esddsp /usr/bin/esdfilt /usr/bin/esdloop /usr/bin/esdmon /usr/bin/esdplay /usr/bin/esdrec /usr/bin/esdsample /usr/bin/exmh-async /usr/bin/exmh-bg /usr/bin/extace /usr/bin/factor /usr/bin/fax2ps /usr/bin/fax2tiff /usr/bin/fifteen_applet /usr/bin/file_by_inode /usr/bin/find2perl /usr/bin/findsmb /usr/bin/fix_bs_and_del /usr/bin/flists /usr/bin/folders /usr/bin/font2c /usr/bin/freecell /usr/bin/ftdump /usr/bin/fterror /usr/bin/ftlint /usr/bin/ftp-ls.sh /usr/bin/ftp-put.sh /usr/bin/ftp-rfc /usr/bin/ftp.expect /usr/bin/ftp.sh /usr/bin/ftstring /usr/bin/ftstrpnm /usr/bin/fttimer /usr/bin/ftview /usr/bin/ftzoom /usr/bin/fwhois /usr/bin/gasp /usr/bin/gcalc /usr/bin/gcolorsel /usr/bin/gconfigger /usr/bin/gcov /usr/bin/gdialog /usr/bin/gdiskfree /usr/bin/gdm /usr/bin/gdmchooser /usr/bin/gdmgreeter /usr/bin/gen_util_applet /usr/bin/gencat /usr/bin/gendiff /usr/bin/getconf /usr/bin/getent /usr/bin/getrom /usr/bin/gettext /usr/bin/gettextize /usr/bin/gfontsel /usr/bin/gftp /usr/bin/ghex /usr/bin/gif2tiff /usr/bin/gimp /usr/bin/gitmkdirs /usr/bin/gitregrep /usr/bin/gitrfgrep /usr/bin/gitwipe /usr/bin/gitxgrep /usr/bin/gless /usr/bin/glibcbug /usr/bin/gmake /usr/bin/gmc /usr/bin/gmenu /usr/bin/gmix /usr/bin/gneqn /usr/bin/gnibbles /usr/bin/gnobots /usr/bin/gnobots2 /usr/bin/gnome-bug /usr/bin/gnome-dump-metadata /usr/bin/gnome-edit /usr/bin/gnome-edit-properties-capplet /usr/bin/gnome-gen-mimedb /usr/bin/gnome-help-browser /usr/bin/gnome-help-caller /usr/bin/gnome-info2html /usr/bin/gnome-linuxconf /usr/bin/gnome-login-check /usr/bin/gnome-man2html /usr/bin/gnome-moz-remote /usr/bin/gnome-name-service /usr/bin/gnome-run /usr/bin/gnome-session /usr/bin/gnome-smproxy /usr/bin/gnome-splash /usr/bin/gnome-stones /usr/bin/gnome-terminal /usr/bin/gnome-wm /usr/bin/gnome_segv /usr/bin/gnomecal /usr/bin/gnomecard /usr/bin/gnomecc /usr/bin/gnomepager_applet /usr/bin/gnomine /usr/bin/gnorpm /usr/bin/gnotravex /usr/bin/gnuchessc /usr/bin/gnuchessn /usr/bin/gnuchessr /usr/bin/gnuchessx /usr/bin/gnumeric /usr/bin/gnumeric-corba /usr/bin/goad-browser /usr/bin/gpenguin /usr/bin/gqview /usr/bin/grun /usr/bin/gsbj /usr/bin/gsdj /usr/bin/gsdj500 /usr/bin/gsearchtool /usr/bin/gslj /usr/bin/gslp /usr/bin/gsnd /usr/bin/gstripchart /usr/bin/gsu /usr/bin/gtali /usr/bin/gtar /usr/bin/gtcd /usr/bin/gtk-shell /usr/bin/gtop /usr/bin/gturing /usr/bin/guile /usr/bin/guname /usr/bin/gusload /usr/bin/gw /usr/bin/gxedit /usr/bin/h2ph /usr/bin/h2xs /usr/bin/helpme /usr/bin/helptool /usr/bin/hltest /usr/bin/hoststat /usr/bin/hwdiag /usr/bin/i386-redhat-linux-gcc /usr/bin/iagno /usr/bin/iambicexample /usr/bin/icombine /usr/bin/iconv /usr/bin/idetool /usr/bin/ifnames /usr/bin/ijoin /usr/bin/imlib_config /usr/bin/infotocap /usr/bin/install-sid /usr/bin/install-todos /usr/bin/ipxdump /usr/bin/ipxparse /usr/bin/isodump /usr/bin/isovfy /usr/bin/itclsh3.0 /usr/bin/itkwish3.0 /usr/bin/jbc_applet /usr/bin/kab /usr/bin/kabalone /usr/bin/kabapi_test /usr/bin/kappfinder /usr/bin/kappfinder_restart /usr/bin/karchie /usr/bin/karm /usr/bin/kattraction.kss /usr/bin/kaudioserver /usr/bin/kbanner.kss /usr/bin/kbat.kss /usr/bin/kbgndwm /usr/bin/kbiff /usr/bin/kblackbox /usr/bin/kblankscrn.kss /usr/bin/kblob.kss /usr/bin/kbouboule.kss /usr/bin/kbsod.kss /usr/bin/kcalc /usr/bin/kcheckpass /usr/bin/kcmbell /usr/bin/kcmdisplay /usr/bin/kcmikbd /usr/bin/kcminfo /usr/bin/kcminput /usr/bin/kcmkeys /usr/bin/kcmkfm /usr/bin/kcmkonsole /usr/bin/kcmkpanel /usr/bin/kcmktalkd /usr/bin/kcmkwm /usr/bin/kcmlocale /usr/bin/kcmsamba /usr/bin/kcmsyssound /usr/bin/kcontrol /usr/bin/kdat /usr/bin/kde /usr/bin/kdecode /usr/bin/kdehelp /usr/bin/kdesetup /usr/bin/kdm /usr/bin/kdmconfig /usr/bin/kdmdesktop /usr/bin/kdvi /usr/bin/kedit /usr/bin/kernelcfg /usr/bin/keyboard-properties /usr/bin/keytab-lilo.pl /usr/bin/kfax /usr/bin/kfdformat /usr/bin/kfind /usr/bin/kfinger /usr/bin/kflame.kss /usr/bin/kfloppy /usr/bin/kfm /usr/bin/kfmclient /usr/bin/kfmexec /usr/bin/kfmsu /usr/bin/kfmsu2 /usr/bin/kfmwarn /usr/bin/kfontmanager /usr/bin/kforest.kss /usr/bin/kfract /usr/bin/kghostview /usr/bin/khexdit /usr/bin/khop.kss /usr/bin/kiconedit /usr/bin/kikbd /usr/bin/kioslave /usr/bin/kjots /usr/bin/klaser.kss /usr/bin/klines.kss /usr/bin/klipper /usr/bin/klissie.kss /usr/bin/kljettool /usr/bin/klock /usr/bin/klpq /usr/bin/kmahjongg /usr/bin/kmail /usr/bin/kmatrix.kss /usr/bin/kmedia /usr/bin/kmenuedit /usr/bin/kmid /usr/bin/kmidi /usr/bin/kmines /usr/bin/kmix /usr/bin/kmkdosfs /usr/bin/kmke2fs /usr/bin/knotes /usr/bin/knu /usr/bin/konquest /usr/bin/konsole /usr/bin/konsole_grantpty /usr/bin/korganizer /usr/bin/korn /usr/bin/kotalkd /usr/bin/kpackage /usr/bin/kpackage_dpkg_ins /usr/bin/kpackage_dpkg_rm /usr/bin/kpackage_slack_l /usr/bin/kpager /usr/bin/kpaint /usr/bin/kpanel /usr/bin/kpat /usr/bin/kpilot /usr/bin/kpilotDaemon /usr/bin/kplayaudio /usr/bin/kpm /usr/bin/kpmdocked /usr/bin/kpoker /usr/bin/kpolygon.kss /usr/bin/kppp /usr/bin/kpppload /usr/bin/kppplogview /usr/bin/kpyro.kss /usr/bin/krdb /usr/bin/kreversi /usr/bin/krn /usr/bin/krock.kss /usr/bin/krootwm /usr/bin/ksame /usr/bin/kscd /usr/bin/kscdmagic /usr/bin/kscience.kss /usr/bin/kshisen /usr/bin/ksirc /usr/bin/kslidescreen.kss /usr/bin/kslip.kss /usr/bin/ksmiletris /usr/bin/ksnake /usr/bin/ksnapshot /usr/bin/ksokoban /usr/bin/kstart /usr/bin/ksticker /usr/bin/kswarm.kss /usr/bin/ksysv /usr/bin/ktalkd /usr/bin/ktalkdlg /usr/bin/kthememgr /usr/bin/ktop /usr/bin/kuser /usr/bin/kview /usr/bin/kwm /usr/bin/kwmcom /usr/bin/kwmsound /usr/bin/kwrite /usr/bin/ld86 /usr/bin/lddlibc4 /usr/bin/lessecho /usr/bin/lha /usr/bin/libgtop-config /usr/bin/libgtop_daemon /usr/bin/libmikmod-config /usr/bin/life_applet /usr/bin/loadshlib /usr/bin/loadunimap /usr/bin/localedef /usr/bin/lpunlock /usr/bin/lz /usr/bin/m4 /usr/bin/mahjongg /usr/bin/mail-files /usr/bin/mail.local /usr/bin/mailserver /usr/bin/mailshar /usr/bin/mailstat /usr/bin/make_printerdef /usr/bin/makedb /usr/bin/makeinfo /usr/bin/mapscrn /usr/bin/mathpod /usr/bin/maudio /usr/bin/mcheck /usr/bin/mcmfmt /usr/bin/mcomp /usr/bin/memos /usr/bin/mime-type-capplet /usr/bin/minfo /usr/bin/mini_commander_applet /usr/bin/mixer_applet /usr/bin/mk_modmap /usr/bin/mkinodedb /usr/bin/mkpreview /usr/bin/mksmbpasswd.sh /usr/bin/modemlights_applet /usr/bin/modemtool /usr/bin/mouse-properties-capplet /usr/bin/mouse-test /usr/bin/msgcmp /usr/bin/msgcomm /usr/bin/msgfmt /usr/bin/msghack /usr/bin/msgmerge /usr/bin/msgunfmt /usr/bin/mtrace /usr/bin/multiload_applet /usr/bin/mxtar /usr/bin/name-client /usr/bin/ncftpbookmarks /usr/bin/neqn /usr/bin/netcfg /usr/bin/netscape /usr/bin/netscape-communicator /usr/bin/new-object /usr/bin/newkrn /usr/bin/nfrm /usr/bin/nntplist /usr/bin/nsupdate /usr/bin/nwdir /usr/bin/old-name-server /usr/bin/orbit-event-server /usr/bin/orbit-ird /usr/bin/orbit-name-server /usr/bin/oxdvi /usr/bin/oxdvi.bin /usr/bin/pal2rgb /usr/bin/perl5.004 /usr/bin/perl5.005 /usr/bin/perl5.00503 /usr/bin/perl5.6 /usr/bin/pi-csd /usr/bin/pi-getram /usr/bin/pi-getrom /usr/bin/pi-nredir /usr/bin/pi-port /usr/bin/pilot-addresses /usr/bin/pilot-clip /usr/bin/pilot-debug /usr/bin/pilot-dedupe /usr/bin/pilot-file /usr/bin/pilot-mail /usr/bin/pilot-schlep /usr/bin/pilot-undelete /usr/bin/pilotListener /usr/bin/pl2pm /usr/bin/plain-gmc /usr/bin/play /usr/bin/pnp_parport /usr/bin/pnp_serial /usr/bin/pod2html /usr/bin/pod2latex /usr/bin/pod2man /usr/bin/ppm2tiff /usr/bin/print_check /usr/bin/printafm /usr/bin/printtool /usr/bin/protoize /usr/bin/pstogif /usr/bin/pstopnm /usr/bin/pstruct /usr/bin/purgestat /usr/bin/pxboard /usr/bin/python /usr/bin/python1.5 /usr/bin/quicklaunch_applet /usr/bin/ras2tiff /usr/bin/rb /usr/bin/rcs-checkin /usr/bin/rcs2log /usr/bin/rcvAppleSingle /usr/bin/rdistd /usr/bin/read-expenses /usr/bin/read-todos /usr/bin/rec /usr/bin/reminders /usr/bin/remsync /usr/bin/reset /usr/bin/rftp /usr/bin/rgb2ycbcr /usr/bin/richtoatk /usr/bin/rlogin-cwd /usr/bin/rman /usr/bin/rpmfind /usr/bin/rtin /usr/bin/run-parts /usr/bin/rx /usr/bin/same-gnome /usr/bin/save-session /usr/bin/saveunimap /usr/bin/sb /usr/bin/screendump /usr/bin/screensaver-properties-capplet /usr/bin/send-pr /usr/bin/seq /usr/bin/session-properties /usr/bin/session-properties-capplet /usr/bin/setfont /usr/bin/setfx /usr/bin/setvesablank /usr/bin/sf2text /usr/bin/sfconvert /usr/bin/sfinfo /usr/bin/sfxtest /usr/bin/slash_applet /usr/bin/smbadduser /usr/bin/smbprint /usr/bin/sndAppleSingle /usr/bin/sol /usr/bin/sound-properties /usr/bin/soxplay /usr/bin/spell /usr/bin/sperl5.00503 /usr/bin/splac /usr/bin/splash /usr/bin/splaymidi /usr/bin/sprof /usr/bin/startkde /usr/bin/su_controlpanel /usr/bin/suidperl /usr/bin/sun-audio-file /usr/bin/sun-message.csh /usr/bin/sun-to-mime /usr/bin/sun2mime /usr/bin/switchdesk /usr/bin/switchdesk-gnome /usr/bin/switchdesk-helper /usr/bin/switchdesk-kde /usr/bin/sx /usr/bin/sync-plan /usr/bin/tcd /usr/bin/tcl /usr/bin/tclhelp /usr/bin/tclsh8.0 /usr/bin/texi2dvi /usr/bin/texindex /usr/bin/text2sf /usr/bin/tgz /usr/bin/theme-selector-capplet /usr/bin/thumbnail /usr/bin/tiff2bw /usr/bin/tiff2ps /usr/bin/tiffcmp /usr/bin/tiffcp /usr/bin/tiffdither /usr/bin/tiffdump /usr/bin/tiffinfo /usr/bin/tiffmedian /usr/bin/tiffsplit /usr/bin/timed-read /usr/bin/timed-run /usr/bin/timetool /usr/bin/tixindex /usr/bin/tixwish4.1.8.0 /usr/bin/tkmib /usr/bin/tkpasswd /usr/bin/trn-artchk /usr/bin/unpack /usr/bin/unprotoize /usr/bin/url-properties /usr/bin/usekde /usr/bin/utmpdump /usr/bin/uulog /usr/bin/uuname /usr/bin/uupick /usr/bin/uuto /usr/bin/uz /usr/bin/vcstime /usr/bin/viamail /usr/bin/vmake /usr/bin/vumeter /usr/bin/weather /usr/bin/webcontrol_applet /usr/bin/wftopfa /usr/bin/whiptail /usr/bin/whois /usr/bin/wish8.0 /usr/bin/wishx /usr/bin/wm-properties-capplet /usr/bin/wmakerconf /usr/bin/workman2cddb.pl /usr/bin/writevt /usr/bin/xchat /usr/bin/xdvi.bin /usr/bin/xgettext /usr/bin/xminicom /usr/bin/xml-config /usr/bin/xproc /usr/bin/xpstat /usr/bin/xsri /usr/bin/zipcloak /usr/bin/zipnote /usr/bin/zipsplit /usr/bin/zless /usr/games/rundoom /usr/games/sdoom /usr/sbin/client /usr/sbin/create-cracklib-dict /usr/sbin/dump-acct /usr/sbin/dump-utmp /usr/sbin/gentest /usr/sbin/gnome-pty-helper /usr/sbin/identconn /usr/sbin/in.timed /usr/sbin/ipop2d /usr/sbin/ipop3d /usr/sbin/itest /usr/sbin/lpf /usr/sbin/mkdict /usr/sbin/ncpserv /usr/sbin/nhfsstone /usr/sbin/nscd /usr/sbin/ntpdate /usr/sbin/ntpq /usr/sbin/ntptime /usr/sbin/ntptrace /usr/sbin/nwbind /usr/sbin/nwconn /usr/sbin/nwserv /usr/sbin/packer /usr/sbin/quotastats /usr/sbin/rdistd /usr/sbin/recover.nvi /usr/sbin/rpc.lockd /usr/sbin/rpcinfo /usr/sbin/safe_finger /usr/sbin/smrsh /usr/sbin/squid /usr/sbin/tickadj /usr/sbin/try-from /usr/sbin/ttmkfdir /usr/sbin/upsconf /usr/sbin/utempter /usr/sbin/utmpd /usr/sbin/uuchk /usr/sbin/uuconv /usr/sbin/uusched /usr/sbin/vigr /usr/sbin/warnquota /usr/sbin/xferstats /usr/sbin/xntpd /usr/sbin/xntpdc
This has been assigned to a developer for further review.
Your concerns are noted, but it would take an army of writers to document all the undocumented parts of Linux. Assigning to tfox to see what she wants to do about it.
This list is too old to work with now. If you still want man pages for these commands, you should file it against that component or the man-pages package instead of putting it all in one bug.