Bug 711852

FYI RHEL 5 equivalent which hasn't been fixed either

https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=690265

Before fix:

[root@ask-03 ~]# rg_test test /etc/cluster/cluster.conf | grep Error
Running in test mode.
Loaded 24 resource rules
Error: Unique attribute collision. type=ASEHAagent attr=sybase_home value=/opt/sybase
Error storing ASEHAagent resource
Error: Reference to nonexistent resource syb_ase2 (type ASEHAagent)

After fix (with scratch rpm):
[root@ask-03 ~]# rg_test test /etc/cluster/cluster.conf | grep ErrorRunning in test mode.
Loaded 24 resource rules
[root@ask-03 ~]#

Created attachment 509850 [details]
Cluster.conf used to replicate bug and test fix

Created attachment 510751 [details]
Patch to fix bz

http://post-office.corp.redhat.com/archives/cluster-list/2011-June/msg00132.html

Chris packages have been tested and results show that the change works as expected.

I believe that the "server_name" parameter should remain unique.

Works as expected with reproducer config.

But according to comment 5 and later also comment 10 the server_name should still be unique and it's not (see the patch). Validation with duplicate server_name still passes the tests, so I'm switching this back to assigned.

Please make server_name unique.

https://www.redhat.com/archives/cluster-devel/2011-October/msg00062.html

Given the simplest possible cluster.conf that would exhibit this behavior:

[root@snap ~]# cat sybasetest.conf 
<cluster>
  <rm>
    <resources>
      <ASEHAagent name="a" sybase_home="b" sybase_ase="c" sybase_ocs="not_unique" server_name="not_unique_test" login_file="a" interfaces_file="a" sybase_user="not_unique" shutdown_timeout="120" start_timeout="120" deep_probe_timeout="120" />
      <ASEHAagent name="b" sybase_home="b" sybase_ase="c" sybase_ocs="not_unique" server_name="not_unique_test" login_file="a" interfaces_file="a" sybase_user="not_unique" shutdown_timeout="120" start_timeout="120" deep_probe_timeout="120" />
    </resources>
  </rm>
</cluster>


Prior to patch (3.9.2-6.el6):

=== Resources List ===
Resource type: ASEHAagent
Agent: ASEHAagent.sh
Attributes:
  name = a [ primary unique ]
  sybase_home = b [ required ]
  sybase_ase = c [ required ]
  sybase_ocs = not_unique [ required ]
  server_name = not_unique_test [ required ]
  login_file = a [ required ]
  interfaces_file = a [ required ]
  sybase_user = not_unique [ required ]
  shutdown_timeout = 120 [ required ]
  start_timeout = 120 [ required ]
  deep_probe_timeout = 120 [ required ]

Resource type: ASEHAagent
Agent: ASEHAagent.sh
Attributes:
  name = b [ primary unique ]
  sybase_home = b [ required ]
  sybase_ase = c [ required ]
  sybase_ocs = not_unique [ required ]
  server_name = not_unique_test [ required ]
  login_file = a [ required ]
  interfaces_file = a [ required ]
  sybase_user = not_unique [ required ]
  shutdown_timeout = 120 [ required ]
  start_timeout = 120 [ required ]
  deep_probe_timeout = 120 [ required ]

=== Event Triggers ===
Event Priority Level 100:
  Name: Default
    (Any event)
    File: /usr/share/cluster/default_event_script.sl

After patch (corrected behavior):

Error: Unique attribute collision. type=ASEHAagent attr=server_name value=not_unique_test
Error storing ASEHAagent resource
Loaded 26 resource rules
=== Resources List ===
Resource type: ASEHAagent
Agent: ASEHAagent.sh
Attributes:
  name = a [ primary unique ]
  sybase_home = b [ required ]
  sybase_ase = c [ required ]
  sybase_ocs = not_unique [ required ]
  server_name = not_unique_test [ unique required ]
  login_file = a [ required ]
  interfaces_file = a [ required ]
  sybase_user = not_unique [ required ]
  shutdown_timeout = 120 [ required ]
  start_timeout = 120 [ required ]
  deep_probe_timeout = 120 [ required ]

=== Event Triggers ===
Event Priority Level 100:
  Name: Default
    (Any event)
    File: /usr/share/cluster/default_event_script.sl

Note both the error storing the second resource with the non-unique value and also the change in flags from [ required ] to [ unique required ]

resource-agents-3.9.2-7.el6.x86_64

works as expected now, server_name unique.

Since the problem described in this bug report should be
resolved in a recent advisory, it has been closed with a
resolution of ERRATA.

For information on the advisory, and where to find the updated
files, follow the link below.

If the solution does not work for you, open a new bug report.

http://rhn.redhat.com/errata/RHSA-2011-1580.html