Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 73131
firstboot detects sound card but does not restart esd
Last modified: 2008-05-01 11:38:03 EDT
Description of Problem:
After installation, on the first user login, the firstboot program starts.
It runs the sound card detector, and the sound card (an Audigy in my case)
is detected, and can play a test sound successfully.
After firstboot finishes, the sound configuration defaults to having no
sound server running, and sound-generating programs such as tuxracer and
xmms will produce no sound.
The sound card detector utility can still play a test sound successfully.
Other applications produce no sound.
If the sound server is enabled, and the user logs out and back in, then
sounds from programs like xmms and tuxracer work properly.
The default behavior should have sounds available to applications in the
first gnome session, as well as subsequent sessions, without manually
(firstname.lastname@example.org states that the defaults are off in the upstream source,
too, and that event sounds should be off because "they suck." I'm not
commenting on the event sounds, but on the proper operation of sound
servers for sound-generating applications such as xmms and tuxracer.)
I don't seem to have this problem. When I do a fresh install, I can start xmms
and hear music without having to change anything. The default volume isn't very
loud, but it certainly seems audible.
However, I've had numerous people tell me that the default is so low that they
can't hear it. It makes me wonder if the default sound level doesn't have
something to do with the hardware. I have two identical test machines at my
desk. Both have integrated Cirrus Logic sound cards. One machine also has a
PCI SoundBlaster. The default sound for the SoundBlaster is much louder than
the Cirrus Logic, which is very quiet. I'm not sure if there's much I can do
However, on my test box which is a fresh install of 8.0, esd gets started when
you log into Gnome. If this is not the case on your machine, it sounds like esd
is the problem, not redhat-config-soundcard.
I have been unable to reproduce this problem with both 8.0 and our latest
internal trees. Resolving as 'worksforme'