Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 75952
Xmms won't play or add any file to a playlist
Last modified: 2014-03-16 22:31:43 EDT
From Bugzilla Helper:
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; U; Linux i686; en-US; rv:1.0.1) Gecko/20020830
Description of problem:
Xmms does not play any file. It simply opens the "Open file" dialog, but after
choosing the file, it won't open the selected file at all.
The same fact happens when trying to add a file to a playlist.
If you open a hand-made playlist, it shows the files in the playlist window, but
when pressing the "Play" button, it won't play anything.
Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable):
Steps to Reproduce:
1.Open/Play a file
2.Open a playlist
3.Add files to a playlist
Actual Results: Nothing: it does not behave the way it should.
Expected Results: Play a file, open a playlist, add files...
email@example.com, were you attempting to play MP3 files?
If so please close this as NOTABUG because MP3 support was removed from Red Hat
8.0. You can easily install the MP3 plugin for XMMS however with
Is it possible that someone make this easier to fix or atleast to find?
I was using xmms with a the xmms-mpg123 plugin and everything was working fine
but when i upgraded using up2date and everything stopped working. Its working
now though because of the file above but took a lot of searching.
Sorry i also meant to add that this affected .ogg files too.
None would play complaining about incorrect plugin but had worked before with
the same plugin.
Hm, that error sounds more like audio configuration rather than the MP3 plugin
issue. What was the exact error?
hmmm, i'm getting the same thing with the new plugin on both mp3 and .ogg files.
The error msg is the same as the one you get when trying to play mp3's from xmms
in its pre-plugged-in state. i.e. the same as before you get plugin.
Can't recreate it. Used to happen when moving from one song in the playlist to
another but if you clicked on the play button it would play. Nothing major but a
little annoying :)
I second Dave O'Connor's comment. Playing an MP3 is perhaps one of the most
common things people do. I experienced the same problem and I ended up (1)
going to Red Hat's site (2) finding Bugzilla (3) signing up for a Bugzilla
account and (4) running 2 bug queries before I figured out the nature of my bug.
I can't believe I spent this much time just trying to figure out how to play
MP3s with my new Red Hat distro. Pardon the rant, but
Does Red Hat think that most customers will be this patient? XMMS is open
source, after all. Red Hat engineers could have added a few lines of code that
would prevent XMMS from failing silently; e.g., a dialog to inform the user
"sorry but the MP3 plugin is not installed ... you need to blah blah blah ..."
prior to officially removing support for MP3s.
It would save thier engineers lots of time dealing with bug reports like this,
but more importantly, it would save customers like me time troubleshooting
something as basic as an MP3 player. Heck, an engineer spending a week on the
problem would probably make Red Hat 6 months of an engineer's salary over the
next several years in the income that was not lost to impatient users getting
frustrated with things like this and just giving up.
I realize Red Hat is not focused on the desktop, but they are leaning
progressively in the direction of trying to capture some desktop space. Imagine
talking a Windows user into giving Linux a shot. What's one of the first things
they're going to do? Try to play their MP3s!
a) this is all documented in the release notes
b) there is a notification plugin; it just had an unfortunate bug
in the 8.0 version, and it's been fixed for roughly 4 to 5 months now.
I understand the legal standpoint but even the plugin you gave still causes the
/me looks around dazedly :)