Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 82331
xchat should default to htmlview
Last modified: 2007-04-18 12:50:11 EDT
From Bugzilla Helper:
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 Galeon/1.2.7 (X11; Linux i686; U;) Gecko/20021216
Description of problem:
When right-clicking on an URL (well, anything looking like a hostname) you get
tons of options:
- Netscape -> open in existing window
-> open in new window
- Galeon -> open in...
I think it should only have "open in web browser" and use htmlview to determine
what the users favorite web browser happens to be. Similarly the amount of "send
url to" options is ridiculous IMHO. Same kind of thing is happening on other
packages as well, for example #80839.
Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): up to and
Steps to Reproduce:
1. rm -rf ~/.xchat
2. xchat &
3. right click on a hostname in the main text area
Actual Results: You get gazillion of options for using software which isn't
even included in RHL, like launching Netscape or Opera.
Expected Results: For better user experience I think it should follow the
settings of user preferred applications and/or htmlview settings.
Created attachment 89460 [details]
Make xchat use htmlview by default
Attached patch does it for english .. but then there are the translations for
which this should be done too :( If you think this would be a good thing I
suppose I can do the patch for the translations as well.
I don't disagree with you about making htmlview part of the xchat browser
menu, and in fact making it the first choice on the menu. I have polled
a few people to see what their opinions were first before presenting my
own, and have had some mixed results. Most people like the idea of putting
htmlview on the menu as "Default web browser" or just "Web Browser", but
most of the people I've talked to like to be able to fire up a URL in
an alternate browser as well, in case a link doesn't work in their default
browser for example.
The only way I can see making a fair decision would be to have a sort of
slashdot poll with 3 or 4 options to choose from. That would be the
fairest approach, but unfortunately the most time consuming as well.
I'm going to leave it for now until I get more feedback from people first,
so that I'm doing what I believe that most users want, and not my own
personal preference, or any one single user's preference.
I'll update the report when I'm ready to make the changes.
I'd be perfectly happy with just having htmlview (described as Default browser,
Web browser.. whatever) as the first entry in the menu. After that, have every
browser in the world listed in the main menu (or perhaps preferably in
submenus), I don't care :)
IMO, switching browsers to work-around bugs is (should be) quite uncommon.
In that case, you can always use X PRIMARY selection and just paste the URL.
Quite often I open up a URL in xchat in mozilla and it wont work properly.
Opening it up in konqueror often results in it working. Many people do this.
At any rate, there is no point debating it here. That just wastes time.
I will add htmlview to the top of the menu sometime. What remains on
the rest of the menu and in what order will be determined at a later
Ok, I've decided that while various people (such as myself even),
will undoubtedly prefer to have a selection of web browsers to
choose from, that the confusion a brand new user might face when
using the application, and seeing so many options, is bad for user
friendliness. Also, the general case is indeed probably that the
majority of users will be just fine with a single default setting,
so changing it to have one setting makes it simpler for the
general case. Advanced/technical users can simply reconfigure
the interface to have whatever other entries they desire, so no
real functionality is lost, just the default settings are being
I have removed the xchat default menu structure now, and replaced
it with a single entry of "Open URL in Web Browser", which uses
htmlview. This will be in 2.0.7-4 in rawhide.
Thanks for the feedback guys, and for your patience waiting for
me to see the light as well. ;o)
Update: I've changed this to use gnome-open instead of htmlview
for Fedora Core 2. The htmlview patch is still included however,
for people who rebuild on older OS releases, and in case I release
erratum for older releases.