Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 1388017
[userinterface_public_502] Should avoid duplicate asking and not contain html syntax <strong> when removing role from self
Last modified: 2017-03-08 13:43 EST
Created attachment 1213379 [details] html syntax and duplicate asking Description of problem: Should avoid duplicate asking and not contain html syntax <strong> when removing role from self Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): v3.4.0.14 How reproducible: Always Steps to Reproduce: 1. Login with admin user 2. Go to "Resources" -> "Membership", click "Edit Membership" 3. Add any role, e.g. view, to yourself 4. Click "X" near one role to remove it from yourself Actual results: 4. As attachment, the pop-up warning contains html syntax <strong>, and the two "Are you sure" questions look like duplicate meaning: Are you sure you want to remove <strong>view</strong> from <strong>xxia</strong> (you)? Are you sure you want to remove view from the user xxia? Expected results: 4. Should avoid duplicate asking (e.g. the second one) and not contain html syntax <strong> when removing role from self. E.g. the warning could look like (role name and user are bold): Are you sure you want to remove view from the user xxia(you)? Additional info:
We always ask for a destructive action, so the modal exists for every "delete". The HTML syntax is probably a duplicate of this bug: https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1388043. I'll address this shortly.
PR open for this: https://github.com/openshift/origin-web-console/pull/718
(In reply to bpeterse from comment #1) > We always ask for a destructive action, so the modal exists for every > "delete". I agree at the modal "Are you sure you want to remove <strong>view</strong> from <strong>xxia</strong> (you)?" for the destruction. But now that this modal exists, the second modal withou 'you' - "Are you sure you want to remove view from the user xxia" looks redundant. So for destructive action, it is better to merge the two asking into one, as suggested in step 4: "Are you sure you want to remove view from the user xxia(you)?". This looks succincter.
Created attachment 1213742 [details] Remove_admin_see_enhanced_warning
New issue when removing "admin" from self: If you (the current login user) have only one role "admin", removing "admin" will show enhanced warning: Removing the role "admin" may completely remove your ability to see this project. (See the new attachment "Remove_admin_see_enhanced_warning") But if you have other role besides "admin", removing "admin" won't show that enhanced warning, as the comment 0 attachment. Should the expected result be: no matter whether you have other role or not, removing "admin" should always show the enhanced warning? Would this be addressed?
Just for clarification, are you seeing two modals (back to back) for one action?
(Sorry, I understood 'modal' as 'confirmation question sentence') Not see two modals. In comment 3, I intended to mean 'asking' instead of 'modal'. I wanted to say: now that this _asking_ exists, the second _asking_ withou 'you' - "Are you sure you want to remove view from the user xxia" looks redundant.
This has been merged into ose and is in OSE v3.4.0.19 or newer.
Checked against v3.4.0.19+346a31d 1. Login with user1, create a project-> Resources -> Membership -> Edit Membership 2. Add 'view' role to yourself Remove one role when there are more than one role 3. Remove "view" role from "user1", will give error: Are you sure you want to remove view from user1 (you)?, click cancel 4. Remove "admin" role from "user1", will give error: Are you sure you want to remove admin from user1 (you)? When the only role is admin, trying to remove "admin" role from yourself will give error: Are you sure you want to remove admin from yapei (you)? Removing the role "admin" may completely remove your ability to see this project Move to verified