Hi Francesco.. Sorry... probably I set the bug to RFE and set to 5.1 thinking that i worked with another bug.... really i do not know, (things that happen when shepherding bugs... :-)

You are right, this is implemented and available in RHCS 5.0 since a couple of weeks ago!!

Thanks!!!

similar problem here https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1954019

your incorrectly using the apply command. you can either use 'ceph orch appy rgw ...." to apply a rgw spec via cli parameters or you can use 'ceph orch apply -i spec.yml' to apply a spec via yaml file

you cant combined 'ceph orch apply rgw ..." and a spec file


in your  example above your doing this "ceph orch apply rgw  rgw.movies  rgw1.yaml"

the correct way to apply your spec file would be "ceph orch apply -i rgw1.yaml"



whats actually happening for you is  your calling the 'apply rgw' cli'     

>>> orch apply rgw <svc_id> [<realm>] [<zone>] [<port:int>] [--ssl]    Update the number of RGW instances for the given zone
>>>  [<placement>] [--dry-run] [--format {plain|json|json-pretty|      
>>>  yaml}] [--unmanaged] [--no-overwrite] 


with the <svc_id> as "rgw.movies" and [<realm>] as "rgw1.yaml"

you can see that is confirmed in the output from the "ceph orch  ls rgw -f yaml" command 

"service_id: rgw.movies"

"spec:
  rgw_realm: rgw1.yaml"

all other parameters of the spec where then defaults. for example the placement was 'count: 2'






additionally the spec you are trying to use does not have a network in it so if applied correctly its not going to bind to a specific network

add "networks: 10.0.208.0/22" to your spec file to use this feature

>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# ceph -s
>>>   cluster:
>>>     id:     0e6bdd12-adba-11eb-92f3-5254003ca783
>>>     health: HEALTH_OK
>>>  
>>>   services:
>>>     mon: 3 daemons, quorum vm-00,vm-02,vm-01 (age 4m)
>>>     mgr: vm-00.gxjgfb(active, since 6m), standbys: vm-01.ptpibf
>>>     osd: 3 osds: 3 up (since 3m), 3 in (since 4m)
>>>  
>>>   data:
>>>     pools:   1 pools, 88 pgs
>>>     objects: 0 objects, 0 B
>>>     usage:   45 MiB used, 450 GiB / 450 GiB avail
>>>     pgs:     1.136% pgs not active
>>>              87 active+clean
>>>              1  peering
>>>  
>>>   progress:
>>>     Global Recovery Event (20s)
>>>       [===========================.] 
>>>  
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# 
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# radosgw-admin realm create --rgw-realm=movies --default
>>> {
>>>     "id": "8365d038-e2e6-4f28-9853-a3f1a216ec4e",
>>>     "name": "movies",
>>>     "current_period": "2944cd0f-39d5-412f-b538-1c27fa8678ce",
>>>     "epoch": 1
>>> }
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# radosgw-admin zonegroup create --rgw-zonegroup=us --master --default 
>>> {
>>>     "id": "340ca1e6-51cd-4c1c-99d7-c3e6d88cf3e9",
>>>     "name": "us",
>>>     "api_name": "us",
>>>     "is_master": "true",
>>>     "endpoints": [],
>>>     "hostnames": [],
>>>     "hostnames_s3website": [],
>>>     "master_zone": "",
>>>     "zones": [],
>>>     "placement_targets": [],
>>>     "default_placement": "",
>>>     "realm_id": "8365d038-e2e6-4f28-9853-a3f1a216ec4e",
>>>     "sync_policy": {
>>>         "groups": []
>>>     }
>>> }
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# radosgw-admin zone create --rgw-zone=us-east --rgw-zonegroup=us --master  --default
>>> {
>>>     "id": "e3406172-8de2-4afc-b1cd-65d555eebe6f",
>>>     "name": "us-east",
>>>     "domain_root": "us-east.rgw.meta:root",
>>>     "control_pool": "us-east.rgw.control",
>>>     "gc_pool": "us-east.rgw.log:gc",
>>>     "lc_pool": "us-east.rgw.log:lc",
>>>     "log_pool": "us-east.rgw.log",
>>>     "intent_log_pool": "us-east.rgw.log:intent",
>>>     "usage_log_pool": "us-east.rgw.log:usage",
>>>     "roles_pool": "us-east.rgw.meta:roles",
>>>     "reshard_pool": "us-east.rgw.log:reshard",
>>>     "user_keys_pool": "us-east.rgw.meta:users.keys",
>>>     "user_email_pool": "us-east.rgw.meta:users.email",
>>>     "user_swift_pool": "us-east.rgw.meta:users.swift",
>>>     "user_uid_pool": "us-east.rgw.meta:users.uid",
>>>     "otp_pool": "us-east.rgw.otp",
>>>     "system_key": {
>>>         "access_key": "",
>>>         "secret_key": ""
>>>     },
>>>     "placement_pools": [
>>>         {
>>>             "key": "default-placement",
>>>             "val": {
>>>                 "index_pool": "us-east.rgw.buckets.index",
>>>                 "storage_classes": {
>>>                     "STANDARD": {
>>>                         "data_pool": "us-east.rgw.buckets.data"
>>>                     }
>>>                 },
>>>                 "data_extra_pool": "us-east.rgw.buckets.non-ec",
>>>                 "index_type": 0
>>>             }
>>>         }
>>>     ],
>>>     "realm_id": "8365d038-e2e6-4f28-9853-a3f1a216ec4e",
>>>     "notif_pool": "us-east.rgw.log:notif"
>>> }
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# radosgw-admin period update --rgw-realm=movies --commit
>>> {
>>>     "id": "e03432c5-603a-4ab1-a922-733f562557e5",
>>>     "epoch": 1,
>>>     "predecessor_uuid": "2944cd0f-39d5-412f-b538-1c27fa8678ce",
>>>     "sync_status": [],
>>>     "period_map": {
>>>         "id": "e03432c5-603a-4ab1-a922-733f562557e5",
>>>         "zonegroups": [
>>>             {
>>>                 "id": "340ca1e6-51cd-4c1c-99d7-c3e6d88cf3e9",
>>>                 "name": "us",
>>>                 "api_name": "us",
>>>                 "is_master": "true",
>>>                 "endpoints": [],
>>>                 "hostnames": [],
>>>                 "hostnames_s3website": [],
>>>                 "master_zone": "e3406172-8de2-4afc-b1cd-65d555eebe6f",
>>>                 "zones": [
>>>                     {
>>>                         "id": "e3406172-8de2-4afc-b1cd-65d555eebe6f",
>>>                         "name": "us-east",
>>>                         "endpoints": [],
>>>                         "log_meta": "false",
>>>                         "log_data": "false",
>>>                         "bucket_index_max_shards": 11,
>>>                         "read_only": "false",
>>>                         "tier_type": "",
>>>                         "sync_from_all": "true",
>>>                         "sync_from": [],
>>>                         "redirect_zone": ""
>>>                     }
>>>                 ],
>>>                 "placement_targets": [
>>>                     {
>>>                         "name": "default-placement",
>>>                         "tags": [],
>>>                         "storage_classes": [
>>>                             "STANDARD"
>>>                         ]
>>>                     }
>>>                 ],
>>>                 "default_placement": "default-placement",
>>>                 "realm_id": "8365d038-e2e6-4f28-9853-a3f1a216ec4e",
>>>                 "sync_policy": {
>>>                     "groups": []
>>>                 }
>>>             }
>>>         ],
>>>         "short_zone_ids": [
>>>             {
>>>                 "key": "e3406172-8de2-4afc-b1cd-65d555eebe6f",
>>>                 "val": 129399253
>>>             }
>>>         ]
>>>     },
>>>     "master_zonegroup": "340ca1e6-51cd-4c1c-99d7-c3e6d88cf3e9",
>>>     "master_zone": "e3406172-8de2-4afc-b1cd-65d555eebe6f",
>>>     "period_config": {
>>>         "bucket_quota": {
>>>             "enabled": false,
>>>             "check_on_raw": false,
>>>             "max_size": -1,
>>>             "max_size_kb": 0,
>>>             "max_objects": -1
>>>         },
>>>         "user_quota": {
>>>             "enabled": false,
>>>             "check_on_raw": false,
>>>             "max_size": -1,
>>>             "max_size_kb": 0,
>>>             "max_objects": -1
>>>         }
>>>     },
>>>     "realm_id": "8365d038-e2e6-4f28-9853-a3f1a216ec4e",
>>>     "realm_name": "movies",
>>>     "realm_epoch": 2
>>> }
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# 
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# 
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# cat spec.yml 
>>> service_type: rgw
>>> service_id: rgw.movies
>>> service_name: rgw.ms.movies
>>> placement:
>>>   hosts:
>>>   - vm-00
>>>   - vm-01
>>> spec:
>>>   rgw_frontend_port: 8080
>>>   rgw_realm: movies
>>>   rgw_zone: us-east
>>> networks: 192.169.142.0/24 
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# 
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# 
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# 
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# ceph orch apply -i spec.yml 
>>> Scheduled rgw.rgw.movies update...
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# 
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# 
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# 
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# ceph orch  ls rgw -f yaml
>>> service_type: rgw
>>> service_id: rgw.movies
>>> service_name: rgw.rgw.movies
>>> placement:
>>>   hosts:
>>>   - vm-00
>>>   - vm-01
>>> networks:
>>> - 192.169.142.0/24
>>> spec:
>>>   rgw_frontend_port: 8080
>>>   rgw_realm: movies
>>>   rgw_zone: us-east
>>> status:
>>>   created: '2021-05-05T16:02:34.550329Z'
>>>   ports:
>>>   - 8080
>>>   running: 0
>>>   size: 2
>>> events:
>>> - 2021-05-05T16:02:32.414256Z service:rgw.rgw.movies [INFO] "service was created"
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# 
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# 
>>> [ceph: root@vm-00 /]# exit
>>> [root@vm-00 ~]#  
>>> [root@vm-00 ~]# 
>>> [root@vm-00 ~]# netstat -plnt | grep radosgw
>>> tcp        0      0 192.169.142.251:8080    0.0.0.0:*               LISTEN      32212/radosgw       
>>> [root@vm-00 ~]# 
>>> [root@vm-00 ~]# ssh vm-01
>>> [root@vm-01 ~]# 
>>> [root@vm-01 ~]# 
>>> [root@vm-01 ~]# netstat -plnt | grep radosgw
>>> tcp        0      0 192.169.142.48:8080     0.0.0.0:*               LISTEN      18248/radosgw       
>>> [root@vm-01 ~]#

Since the problem described in this bug report should be
resolved in a recent advisory, it has been closed with a
resolution of ERRATA.

For information on the advisory (Red Hat Ceph Storage 5.0 bug fix and enhancement), and where to find the updated
files, follow the link below.

If the solution does not work for you, open a new bug report.

https://access.redhat.com/errata/RHBA-2021:3294