Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 22687
xinetd.conf: Please consider removing RECORD option
Last modified: 2007-04-18 12:30:18 EDT
Please see the summary line.
I think the RECORD option should be removed from the default config; it is
a security risk. As well as being a risk, it also brings very little
benefit to an installation, as it only kicks in when the target service
cannot be launched!
The reasons for this being a security risk are:
- Lots of parsing/logging of malicious remote supplied data (usernames,
- In the case of "rexec", a 1-byte overflow (xinetd author informed)
- Dangerous "connect back" facility, which mixed in with a bit of spoofing,
can allow a malicious remote to force a host to make connections to
privileged ports from privileged ports.
Done, in xinetd-220.127.116.11pre13-4
However, removing the RECORD option generates the following error message:
Jan 21 05:29:38 test1 xinetd: xinetd shutdown succeeded
Jan 21 05:29:38 test1 xinetd: Bad log-on_failure flag: PID [line=11]
This is in beta2. I have no objections to removing the RECORD option but in xinetd-18.104.22.168pre13-5
the settings are:
log_on_success = HOST PID
log_on_failure = HOST PID
and that craps out with the error message above.
Sorry I guess I need to be more exact. By crapping out I mean it generates the noted error message and continues.
Fixed in xinetd-22.214.171.124pre14-3
*** Bug 28049 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***