Red Hat Bugzilla – Bug 55637
undefined references/bookmarks for elements inside tables
Last modified: 2007-04-18 12:38:00 EDT
Description of Problem: (Already reported on Sourceforge - bug #452540) I'm using Norman Walsh's stylesheets and every indexterm defined in a entry in a table does NOT get its page number resolved in the index. E.g. I get LaTeX Warning: Reference `IDX-ICONTROL' on page 211 undefined on input line 89746. If I inspect the .tex file, the label seems to be defined (at least apparently): $ grep -15 IDX-ICONTROL *tex auisg.tex-\TableCell% auisg.tex-{\def\CellRowAlignment% auisg.tex-{start}\def\CellBeforeRowMargin% auisg.tex-{3\p@}\def\CellAfterRowMargin% auisg.tex-{3\p@}\def\CellBeforeColumnMargin% auisg.tex-{0\p@}\def\CellAfterColumnMargin% auisg.tex-{3\p@}\def\StartIndent% auisg.tex-{2\p@}\def\StartIndentFactor% auisg.tex-{0}\def\EndIndent% auisg.tex-{2\p@}\def\EndIndentFactor% auisg.tex-{0}}\Par% auisg.tex-{\def\fFamName{Times-New-Roman}\def\fWeight% auisg.tex-{medium}\def\Quadding% auisg.tex-{start}} \Node% auisg.tex-{\def\Label% auisg.tex:{IDX-ICONTROL}}\Seq% auisg.tex-{}\endSeq{}\endNode{} auisg.tex- IControl\endPar{}\endTableCell{}% auisg.tex-}% auisg.tex-&\TeXTableCell{1}{T{0\p@}{347\p@}{3\p@}}% auisg.tex-{% auisg.tex-\TableCell% auisg.tex-{\def\CellRowAlignment% auisg.tex-{start}\def\CellBeforeRowMargin% auisg.tex-{3\p@}\def\CellAfterRowMargin% auisg.tex-{3\p@}\def\CellBeforeColumnMargin% auisg.tex-{0\p@}\def\CellAfterColumnMargin% auisg.tex-{3\p@}\def\StartIndent% auisg.tex-{2\p@}\def\StartIndentFactor% auisg.tex-{0}\def\EndIndent% auisg.tex-{2\p@}\def\EndIndentFactor% -- auisg.tex-{\def\Label% auisg.tex-{X287}}\endNode{}\endLink{}\endNode{} auisg.tex- \endPar{}\endNode{}\Node% auisg.tex-{\def\Element% auisg.tex-{8158}}\Par% auisg.tex-{\def\fSize% auisg.tex-{9\p@}\def\StartIndent% auisg.tex-{58\p@}\def\StartIndentFactor% auisg.tex-{0}}preferences editor, auisg.tex- \Node% auisg.tex-{\def\Element% auisg.tex-{8159}}\Seq% auisg.tex-{\def\fWeight% auisg.tex-{bold}}\Link% auisg.tex-{\def\Label% auisg.tex:{IDX-ICONTROL}}\Node% auisg.tex-{\def\Label% auisg.tex:{IDX-ICONTROL}\def\ProcessingMode% auisg.tex-{toc-page-number-mode}}\insertCurrentNodePageNumber% auisg.tex-{\def\Label% auisg.tex:{IDX-ICONTROL}}\endNode{}\endLink{}\endSeq{}\endNode{} auisg.tex- \endPar{}\endNode{}\endNode{}\Node% auisg.tex-{\def\Element% auisg.tex-{8161}}\Node% auisg.tex-{\def\Element% auisg.tex-{8162}}\Par% auisg.tex-{\def\fSize% auisg.tex-{9\p@}}IDs, auisg.tex- \Node% auisg.tex-{\def\Element% auisg.tex-{8163}}\Link% auisg.tex-{\def\Label% auisg.tex-{X289}}\Node% auisg.tex-{\def\Label% auisg.tex-{X289}\def\ProcessingMode% auisg.tex-{toc-page-number-mode}}\insertCurrentNodePageNumber% That's why I'm reporting this as a bug in jadetex, not db-style-dsssl. The labels never appear in the aux file, no matter how many times I run jadetex. The above is all I can submit (the whole .tex file is a couple of megabytes), but see below for a simple testcase. Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): All, AFAICS. How Reproducible: Always Steps to Reproduce: 1. See below 2. 3. Actual Results: "Undefined reference" errors in jadetex output Expected Results: Correct hyperlinks and references in final output. Additional Information: Peter Eisentraut (petere78@sourceforge) adds: Just having encountered the same problem, I just wanted to add some of my own obervations. This is not really dependent on indexterms. Any link will do. Process the following document with DSSSL stylesheets 1.70 or so and JadeTeX 3.10. I agree with the original posters assessment that the .tex file looks correct, all the targets seem to be defined. Note also that if the link is to the <table> element, everything works correctly. <!DOCTYPE book PUBLIC "-//OASIS//DTD DocBook V3.1//EN"> <book> <title>My Book</title> <chapter> <title>First Chapter</title> <para> See also <link linkend="foo">elsewhere</link> </para> </chapter> <chapter> <title>Second Chapter</title> <table> <title>Some Table</title> <tgroup cols=2> <tbody> <row> <entry id="foo">one</entry> <entry>two</entry> </row> </tbody> </tgroup> </table> </chapter> </book>
The SGML test case seems to be a different problem to the one that your auisg.tex file is exhibiting. For the SGML test case, I don't see the reference defined in the tex output. (This seems to be an openjade bug.) There is another bug (sf bug #443192) that hampers test cases containing an index. With jadetex-3.11-3 (yet to be pushed to rawhide) this is worked around; also it is not present in jadetex < 3.11. It would be helpful if you could find: - a minimal test case that exhibits the bug whereby correct TeX output from openjade gives incorrect DVI output from jadetex - which package versions you are using for jadetex, openjade and docbook-style-dsssl. Thanks.
Created attachment 36901 [details] Testcase
This test case has no index, and the DVI seems fine. Did you mean to have index as 'IGNORE'?
This is how to reproduce the bug using the testcase I attached. Generate the index using the HTML backend: openjade -t sgml -i html -V html-index -d /usr/share/sgml/docbook/utils-0.6.9/docbook-utils.dsl#html indexbug.sgml Create the SGML markup for the index: collateindex.pl -p -o term.idx HTML.index(omitting -p doesn't seem to make any difference) Generate the .tex file, this time setting "index" so that the index markup in term.idx gets included: openjade -t tex -i print -V tex-backend -i index -d /usr/share/sgml/docbook/utils-0.6.9/docbook-utils.dsl#print indexbug.sgml Now run either pdfjadetex or jadetex on indexbug.tex. You should get undefined references, although IDX-ICONTROL seems to be defined if you look at the TeX source. There's also a note in the index if you open the PDF file, with the path to the HTML link target. I had never seen such behaviour before. I'm using the very latest packages from RawHide: $ rpm -q openjade docbook-style-dsssl docbook-utils docbook-utils-pdf jadetex tetex openjade-1.3-21 docbook-style-dsssl-1.73-3 docbook-utils-0.6.9-6 docbook-utils-pdf-0.6.9-6 jadetex-3.11-3 tetex-1.0.7-35
Excellent, thanks.
Yes, I always have the index ignored by default, to prevent "chicken and egg" problems when rebuilding everything from scratch. After the index markup has been created, "-i index" is always passed to openjade. This saves one attachment ;) and also makes sure there can't be problems due to inconsistencies between the index and the rest of the document.
I merged the index and the document together to create a single file test case. I'll attach the DocBook and the FOT here.
Created attachment 37006 [details] DocBook test case
Created attachment 37007 [details] FOT test case
'Red Hat Raw Hide' refers to the development tree for Red Hat Linux. Red Hat Linux is no longer supported by Red Hat, Inc. If you are still running Red Hat Linux, you are strongly advised to upgrade to a current Fedora Core release or Red Hat Enterprise Linux or comparable. Some information on which option may be right for you is available at http://www.redhat.com/rhel/migrate/redhatlinux/. Red Hat apologizes that these issues were not resolved in a more timely manner. However, we do want to make sure that important don't slip through the cracks. If these issues are still present in a current release, such as Fedora Core 5, please move these bugs to that product and version. Note that any remaining Red Hat Raw Hide bugs will be closed as 'CANTFIX' on September 30, 2006. Thanks again for your help.
Red Hat Linux is no longer supported by Red Hat, Inc. If you are still running Red Hat Linux, you are strongly advised to upgrade to a current Fedora Core release or Red Hat Enterprise Linux or comparable. Some information on which option may be right for you is available at http://www.redhat.com/rhel/migrate/redhatlinux/. Closing as CANTFIX.