Created attachment 745252 [details] engine log Description of problem: import vm action fails due to missing storage domain type. However that parameter is missing both in automatic completion and in the RSDL file, therefore the action can't be completed. Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): SF15 How reproducible: 100% Steps to Reproduce: [RHEVM shell (connected)]# action vm Migrations_VM-0 export --storage_domain-name export id : ba2cf2da-55f4-400e-bcec-ddaa64b8476e async : True status-state : pending storage_domain-name: export [RHEVM shell (connected)]# remove vm Migrations_VM-0 accepted. [RHEVM shell (connected)]# list vms --storagedomain-identifier 95c9ab87-1386-4904-b27d-1d26714704a7 id : 954b1f6e-b2ea-4c08-a95e-6182084be971 name : Migrations_VM-1 id : 46165888-5b2e-449d-8faa-5c0fe43613a2 name : test3 id : bae28aa8-6c26-415a-bce4-b72a2dda1688 name : Migrations_VM-0 id : d658c1c5-cbcd-4b72-8ba0-1bb2a27ead88 name : Migrations_VM-2 [RHEVM shell (connected)]# action vm bae28aa8-6c26-415a-bce4-b72a2dda1688 import_vm --storagedomain-identifier 95c9ab87-1386-4904-b27d-1d26714704a7 --cluster-name Migrations_DC1_CL1 --storage_domain-name export --async False error: status: 400 reason: Bad Request detail: Cannot import VM. Storage Domain type not specified. Actual results: operation fails Expected results: Expecting to have such an option / or remove the error in order to make the operation success Additional info:
Barak, looks like you confused between destination and source storage domains, can you check this please?
Michael, You are right, I couldn't tell which is the source and which is the destination as one is called storagedomain-identifier and the other storage_domain-name. 1) The Error has nothing to do with the action - storage domain type is not the issue. 2) The parameters names are confusing, should be storage_domain_source_name|id and storage_domain_dest_name|id 3) I couldn't find the right usage under help action vm
(In reply to comment #3) > Michael, > > You are right, I couldn't tell which is the source and which is the > destination as one is called storagedomain-identifier and the other > storage_domain-name. > > 1) The Error has nothing to do with the action - storage domain type is not > the issue. > > 2) The parameters names are confusing, should be > storage_domain_source_name|id and storage_domain_dest_name|id > > 3) I couldn't find the right usage under help action vm the parameters names cannot be changed cause they are exposed/used like this in api, #2 and #3 can be easily achieved by adding descriptions to these params in RSDL
*** Bug 961352 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
(In reply to comment #4) > (In reply to comment #3) > > Michael, > > > > You are right, I couldn't tell which is the source and which is the > > destination as one is called storagedomain-identifier and the other > > storage_domain-name. > > > > 1) The Error has nothing to do with the action - storage domain type is not > > the issue. > > > > 2) The parameters names are confusing, should be > > storage_domain_source_name|id and storage_domain_dest_name|id > > > > 3) I couldn't find the right usage under help action vm > > > the parameters names cannot be changed cause they are exposed/used like Right, but we can introduce a new API with proper names and mark the old one as deprecated. > this in api, #2 and #3 can be easily achieved by adding descriptions to these > params in RSDL This would be good as well for the transition period.
This bug is referenced in ovirt-engine-3.4.0-beta3 logs. Moving to ON_QA
This bug was fixed and is slated to be in the upcoming version. As we are focusing our testing at this phase on severe bugs, this bug was closed without going through its verification step. If you think this bug should be verified by QE, please set its severity to high and move it back to ON_QA
Verified on ovirt-3.4.0-beta3: new description in rsdl only ( /api/storagedomains/{storagedomain:id}/templates/{template:id}/import"): "import the template from the export or data domain identified by storagedomain-identifier into the destination storage domain identified by storage_domain.id|name" instead of "import the template from the export or data domain into the specified cluster" for vms (/api/storagedomains/{storagedomain:id}/vms/{vm:id}/import): "import the specified virtual machine from the source storagedomain identified by storagedomain-identifier into the destination storage domain identified by storage_domain.id|name" However, the auto complete feature enable the source & then the destination, which make sense.